6 Comments
User's avatar
Angela Thomas's avatar

Just a clarification. The districts will be drawn by an independent redistricting committee based on a new law that went into effect on Aug 12, 2026. HB26-1038 lays that out.

Michael D Brown's avatar

That's a genuinely useful correction, and you're right on the core of it. Thanks! HB26-1038 passed this year and changes exactly what I described. Under the old law, county commissioners were the only partisan office in Colorado that got to draw their own district maps. The new law takes that pen away and hands it to an independent redistricting commission — equal parts Republicans, Democrats, and unaffiliated voters, with the sitting commissioners barred from serving on it. So my line about the board drawing its own lines is now out of date, and you've corrected it. That's on me, and I'd rather fix it than pretend I got it perfect.

One small refinement to your version however. The board isn't entirely out of it. Under the law, the commissioners still appoint the commission's members, and depending on how it's set up, still choose the final map from the plans the commission sends up. So it's a real check on self-dealing — a big one — but it's "local control with guardrails," not a fully hands-off process. Worth being precise about.

But here's what I find fascinating, and it actually goes to the heart of what I argued. This strengthens the point I was making, not weakens it. My concern was that single-member districts guarantee the growing north end its own seat — and that this cuts against a lot of the folks cheering for expansion. Well, an independent commission drawing competitive maps by a public formula makes that even more certain. A friendly board might at least have tried to draw those lines to dilute the north end's influence. An independent commission won't. Which means the double-edge I described is sharper now, not duller: the people who think districts will protect the old majority are counting on a mapmaker who, by law, isn't going to play that game.

I admit the additional facts but the conclusion holds. Appreciate you making the piece more accurate. This is exactly the kind of correction worth having.

Frank Eich's avatar

Absolutely agree. 5 commissioners and 5 districts. Current board members….and the process….are all untenable! As a resident in “unincorporated Douglas County” (south of Parker) feel fortunate that we escaped Highlands Ranch in 2001 as it has turned light blue. Yuk!

JEANNETTE's avatar

9 votes for 340 million + . I imagine you are for packing Supreme Court also? The 3 old commissioners did things at times I did not agree with but too many opinions means too much time needed to agree. And Take Covid. I’m thankful we were not mandated to do a lot of things and 2 out of the 3 saved us.

Michael D Brown's avatar

On the Supreme Court — no, and the comparison doesn't hold, and you've actually walked onto my home field here. Court-packing means changing the size of a body specifically to change its rulings — no trigger, no threshold, just outcome-shopping. Expanding a county commission is a population trigger that's been sitting in Colorado law for decades, and Adams, Arapahoe, and El Paso already did it. And nine justices for 340 million is one court for an entire continent — nobody's arguing a county of 400,000 is over-represented at five. If anything, more seats makes a board harder to capture, not easier. Court-packing concentrates control. This does the opposite.

But your COVID point is the real one, and I'm not going to duck it, because it's the best thing in your comment. You're right: two votes blocked the mandates, and you're grateful. So am I.

Here's what I'd ask you to consider, though. What protected you wasn't that the board was small. It was that the right two were in the chairs. A three-member board is a coin flip — the same structure that let two conservatives protect you is the structure that lets any two people run this whole county the day the composition changes. You didn't get lucky because there were three. You got lucky because of which three.

That's my whole argument, and COVID proves it better than I could. Two votes deciding everything worked out for us that time. I don't want my kids' liberty riding on it working out every time. Five seats doesn't undo what those two commissioners did for us. It means the next fight doesn't come down to a coin flip.