Yes! And thanks for giving us the background that gets lost through the years. I just wish more Republicans would speak out in support of Taiwan (and also Ukraine.)
Absolutely must protect Taiwan. Our ability to build (and staff) fabs, at the scale necessary to maintain commerce, does not exist. Look at the opposition to data enter buildout we have today. Fabs will encounter the same headwinds.
A Blockade Is an Act of Aggression, Not a Peaceful Measure. The strongest case is not that Taiwan is worth a war by itself. The stronger argument is that allowing a blockade to succeed would fundamentally damage U.S. security, economic interests, and global credibility. Taiwan matters economically: Taiwan sits astride critical shipping routes in East Asia and is a major producer of advanced semiconductors that power everything from smartphones to military systems. Additionally, if the United States stands aside while a blockade succeeds, allies may doubt American commitments and seek other ways to protect themselves, potentially destabilizing the region. History often shows that unchecked aggression can encourage further demands. If a powerful state can close major sea lanes through intimidation, it undermines a principle that benefits all trading nations, including the United States. Yes, I would send the Navy to break a Chinese blockade of Taiwan. A blockade is an act of coercion designed to achieve political objectives through force. If the United States allows it to succeed, it would undermine freedom of navigation, damage the global economy, weaken confidence in American commitments, and encourage future aggression. While intervention carries risks, including escalation with China, the costs of inaction could be even greater. Maintaining open sea lanes, supporting regional stability, and preserving deterrence are vital American interests that justify naval action.
Colette, thank you. That's the question I hoped people would wrestle with, and you made the case better than I did in one important way. You named the blockade for what it is: coercion.
Here's a piece of history that backs you up. In October 1962, when Kennedy ordered the Navy to stop Soviet ships headed for Cuba, his administration deliberately called it a "quarantine." Under international law, a blockade is an act of war. Beijing understands that distinction too, which is why its drill last December rehearsed a blockade without calling it one, and why its August "traffic control" order came wrapped in a typhoon warning.
Your point about unchecked aggression inviting further demands is where Part Two picks up. It's about Britain, and what happens to a country, and its people, when it can no longer enforce the rules it used to write.
I agree with Colette. After all it was America's inaction to begin with that started all this. Just as it was Britain's inaction that got them into WWII.
And, when will American companies stop "getting rid" of "old" technology allowing other countries to run with it? What is happening now with Taiwan is the result of arrogance in American technocrats who probably thought they were giving yellow-skined nuckleheads something flimsy to play with. Smh.
Thanks for another great history lesson, and yes, I would send the Navy to break a Chinese blockade. For all the reasons you discussed and those shared by others in their comments - plus one. Communism. Communists/socialists play the long game. Their outsized influence in the USA through our higher education shows it. China doesn't want Taiwan for the chips, they want it for the military advantage it gives them. They want it because from there they can take the next step to world dominance. They partner with Iran for the same reason. Why should the US provide the deterrence to China? Because if we don't nobody will - history has proven that numerous times - and China knows it. No other country has the strength or guts (although we are sometimes too fearful ourselves.) You mentioned the current situation with Iran, and the cost of gas. What would have happened if some other president(s) had had the guts Trump does, and had dealt properly with Iran and deterred them from pursuing their obvious ambitions - would the price of oil, and the middle-east, be more stable now? I think so. But we waited until the cost of deterrence is almost more than the public is willing to accept - yet, it still needs to be done, because if we stop now it will only be worse the next time we decide to try. This brings to mind an old adage - If not now, when? If not us, who? Sometimes you just have to roll up your sleeves, get dirty, and do what needs to be done.
Thank you Mike for this recap of history. I would arm Taiwan with nukes to allow them the ultimate defensive posture, not merely the threat of a "chip kill switch". May as well face the rapidly increasing Chinese threat to global peace sooner rather than later. I fear the Strait of China will rapidly become our "Munich Moment". This clock is ticking.
Yes! And thanks for giving us the background that gets lost through the years. I just wish more Republicans would speak out in support of Taiwan (and also Ukraine.)
Absolutely must protect Taiwan. Our ability to build (and staff) fabs, at the scale necessary to maintain commerce, does not exist. Look at the opposition to data enter buildout we have today. Fabs will encounter the same headwinds.
''Michael D[anger]. brown is a national treasure.''
pass it on.
Day Umm...
A Blockade Is an Act of Aggression, Not a Peaceful Measure. The strongest case is not that Taiwan is worth a war by itself. The stronger argument is that allowing a blockade to succeed would fundamentally damage U.S. security, economic interests, and global credibility. Taiwan matters economically: Taiwan sits astride critical shipping routes in East Asia and is a major producer of advanced semiconductors that power everything from smartphones to military systems. Additionally, if the United States stands aside while a blockade succeeds, allies may doubt American commitments and seek other ways to protect themselves, potentially destabilizing the region. History often shows that unchecked aggression can encourage further demands. If a powerful state can close major sea lanes through intimidation, it undermines a principle that benefits all trading nations, including the United States. Yes, I would send the Navy to break a Chinese blockade of Taiwan. A blockade is an act of coercion designed to achieve political objectives through force. If the United States allows it to succeed, it would undermine freedom of navigation, damage the global economy, weaken confidence in American commitments, and encourage future aggression. While intervention carries risks, including escalation with China, the costs of inaction could be even greater. Maintaining open sea lanes, supporting regional stability, and preserving deterrence are vital American interests that justify naval action.
Colette, thank you. That's the question I hoped people would wrestle with, and you made the case better than I did in one important way. You named the blockade for what it is: coercion.
Here's a piece of history that backs you up. In October 1962, when Kennedy ordered the Navy to stop Soviet ships headed for Cuba, his administration deliberately called it a "quarantine." Under international law, a blockade is an act of war. Beijing understands that distinction too, which is why its drill last December rehearsed a blockade without calling it one, and why its August "traffic control" order came wrapped in a typhoon warning.
Your point about unchecked aggression inviting further demands is where Part Two picks up. It's about Britain, and what happens to a country, and its people, when it can no longer enforce the rules it used to write.
I agree with Colette. After all it was America's inaction to begin with that started all this. Just as it was Britain's inaction that got them into WWII.
And, when will American companies stop "getting rid" of "old" technology allowing other countries to run with it? What is happening now with Taiwan is the result of arrogance in American technocrats who probably thought they were giving yellow-skined nuckleheads something flimsy to play with. Smh.
Thanks for another great history lesson, and yes, I would send the Navy to break a Chinese blockade. For all the reasons you discussed and those shared by others in their comments - plus one. Communism. Communists/socialists play the long game. Their outsized influence in the USA through our higher education shows it. China doesn't want Taiwan for the chips, they want it for the military advantage it gives them. They want it because from there they can take the next step to world dominance. They partner with Iran for the same reason. Why should the US provide the deterrence to China? Because if we don't nobody will - history has proven that numerous times - and China knows it. No other country has the strength or guts (although we are sometimes too fearful ourselves.) You mentioned the current situation with Iran, and the cost of gas. What would have happened if some other president(s) had had the guts Trump does, and had dealt properly with Iran and deterred them from pursuing their obvious ambitions - would the price of oil, and the middle-east, be more stable now? I think so. But we waited until the cost of deterrence is almost more than the public is willing to accept - yet, it still needs to be done, because if we stop now it will only be worse the next time we decide to try. This brings to mind an old adage - If not now, when? If not us, who? Sometimes you just have to roll up your sleeves, get dirty, and do what needs to be done.
Thank you Mike for this recap of history. I would arm Taiwan with nukes to allow them the ultimate defensive posture, not merely the threat of a "chip kill switch". May as well face the rapidly increasing Chinese threat to global peace sooner rather than later. I fear the Strait of China will rapidly become our "Munich Moment". This clock is ticking.