At a 9/11 remembrance event Sunday evening, a room full of good people misunderstood seven months. Here is what really happened on a hill in Staten Island.
Michael, this took my breath away. I have a dear friend who was a Fire Captain in Brooklyn during 9/11. One of his guys asked him if Joe could work for him the night of September 10. Joe worked a double shift that day and night so one of his crew could be where he needed to be. The next morning as he was returning home after the shift ended, he saw the smoke. He got back to the site as soon as possible. He found the member of his Truck who was assigned to stay with the Truck. The man was obviously in shock. He asked where the rest of the crew was and was told they were all gone, including the man he had worked for the previous evening. That man and the rest of the crew were gone, never to be found, as he would have been had he not done a favor for someone. He and his wife now live in Florida but they return every year for the Memorials. It is equally heart breaking every year. I have forwarded this to Joe whom I know will greatly appreciate that you shared this information I am sure he has never heard before.
Thank you, Susan. It never really dawned on me that many people might not know the story. I think the audience last night was just a reminder that they either didn't know, don't remember, or were just aghast that it would take that long. But there was a reason it took that long. Now they know.
Hello, Stacey. I am so grateful for your sharing that. Wish I could give you a big hug. All of those workers spent all of that time, energy, effort for you and all the others who lost someone that day and thought they would never get them back.
As I am sure you are aware, that work continues today in a discreet Medical Examiner's Office at the Ground Zero Museum every single day.
Mr. Brown, I witnessed this start to happen from a vantage point half a country away, and deep down inside I understood what would be the conclusion before it came to pass. I am sincerely grateful for your candor. May you know The Holy Ghost as a Comforter, Consellor, Companion and Friend.
Hell of a piece. I never knew any of this history, and I am certain many of my peers wouldn't, either (I'm 41). I'm amazed at the new 9/ll stories that have popped up during this mournful 25 year old anniversary. This piece, like newer images that show graphic imagery, or tell of extremely difficult moments, are still emerging, 25 years later. That, to me, is amazing.
It reminds me in a sense of the Dude44Bravo airman we rescued on Easter Sunday in Iran. He trusted that his fellow Americans would find him. He always held faith, and he was as proud as could be as he watched the Americans rescue his teammate, Alpha. (All of this was on 60 Minutes on Sunday.)
I hope it's true, because it's a truly beautiful story of American heroism and resiliance.
But back to your piece - not enough people know this history. Not enough Americans appreciate the hell that so many workers suffered so that families could find answers, not to mention all of those injured by 9/11 air quality as they drove back and forth between sites.
Thankfully, no other county has had to recreate such horrific circumstances, with exception perhaps of the good people of Lockerbie, Scotland, who volunteered for difficult jobs like these in our shared tragedy. But as Americans we show that even at Fresh Kills (quite a name), where federal agents worked endlessly to identify minute fragments that might give a family an answer of some kind, even if it could never bring back their loved one.
Why would we spend all of this time and resources on a mission where I'm betting other countries and parties would calculate the ROI and not act as we would?
Why? Because we're Americans. We don't quit on each other, even if we're bastards to each half the time. And when all hell breaks loose, people forget what political beliefs the person next to them might have. We all work together to help each other and try to fix the situation - and while I know we're not perfect, there's no where on this Earth I'd rather be. We'll always be striving toward the more perfect union. This piece encourages me as I share that hope.
This is so beautifully written; thank you for persevering to tell the story, even if it took decades. There is so much to be said for those who do the unglamorous jobs of cleaning up the aftermath of the most horrific crimes and incidents. (Of course, 9/11 was on a whole other level as far as incidents.) The piece is incredibly befitting of the respect and honor these workers and are due. They are the best of us.
These are many ways you could criticize the government regarding 9/11.
This isn't one.
Thank you.
I think the thing I appreciate the most is how you are able to express and hold the various experiences and viewpoints simultaneously. This isn't relativism. This is the human experience.
I have a picture from when I was working on disaster recovery for American Express. Part of our work brought us into Manhattan to do some migrations for them and I walked over to the site while they were honoring a fireman being pulled from the wreckage on March 12, 2022. The wrong side of the gasp witnessed by Michael can be better understood by Justine what was happening at the site well into 22.
That's interesting because one of my first things to do while the pit was being cleared, was visit the surrounding buildings, including the Amex building. I can remember walking up the escalators and using that elevation to look over at Ground Zero. Maybe we crossed paths that day.
Michael, this took my breath away. I have a dear friend who was a Fire Captain in Brooklyn during 9/11. One of his guys asked him if Joe could work for him the night of September 10. Joe worked a double shift that day and night so one of his crew could be where he needed to be. The next morning as he was returning home after the shift ended, he saw the smoke. He got back to the site as soon as possible. He found the member of his Truck who was assigned to stay with the Truck. The man was obviously in shock. He asked where the rest of the crew was and was told they were all gone, including the man he had worked for the previous evening. That man and the rest of the crew were gone, never to be found, as he would have been had he not done a favor for someone. He and his wife now live in Florida but they return every year for the Memorials. It is equally heart breaking every year. I have forwarded this to Joe whom I know will greatly appreciate that you shared this information I am sure he has never heard before.
Bless you!
Thank you, Susan. It never really dawned on me that many people might not know the story. I think the audience last night was just a reminder that they either didn't know, don't remember, or were just aghast that it would take that long. But there was a reason it took that long. Now they know.
Thanks to you! 😊
Thank you for telling the story. It is because of those workers in white that part of my husband came back to me. I will forever be grateful.
Hello, Stacey. I am so grateful for your sharing that. Wish I could give you a big hug. All of those workers spent all of that time, energy, effort for you and all the others who lost someone that day and thought they would never get them back.
As I am sure you are aware, that work continues today in a discreet Medical Examiner's Office at the Ground Zero Museum every single day.
Mr. Brown, I witnessed this start to happen from a vantage point half a country away, and deep down inside I understood what would be the conclusion before it came to pass. I am sincerely grateful for your candor. May you know The Holy Ghost as a Comforter, Consellor, Companion and Friend.
Hell of a piece. I never knew any of this history, and I am certain many of my peers wouldn't, either (I'm 41). I'm amazed at the new 9/ll stories that have popped up during this mournful 25 year old anniversary. This piece, like newer images that show graphic imagery, or tell of extremely difficult moments, are still emerging, 25 years later. That, to me, is amazing.
It reminds me in a sense of the Dude44Bravo airman we rescued on Easter Sunday in Iran. He trusted that his fellow Americans would find him. He always held faith, and he was as proud as could be as he watched the Americans rescue his teammate, Alpha. (All of this was on 60 Minutes on Sunday.)
I hope it's true, because it's a truly beautiful story of American heroism and resiliance.
But back to your piece - not enough people know this history. Not enough Americans appreciate the hell that so many workers suffered so that families could find answers, not to mention all of those injured by 9/11 air quality as they drove back and forth between sites.
Thankfully, no other county has had to recreate such horrific circumstances, with exception perhaps of the good people of Lockerbie, Scotland, who volunteered for difficult jobs like these in our shared tragedy. But as Americans we show that even at Fresh Kills (quite a name), where federal agents worked endlessly to identify minute fragments that might give a family an answer of some kind, even if it could never bring back their loved one.
Why would we spend all of this time and resources on a mission where I'm betting other countries and parties would calculate the ROI and not act as we would?
Why? Because we're Americans. We don't quit on each other, even if we're bastards to each half the time. And when all hell breaks loose, people forget what political beliefs the person next to them might have. We all work together to help each other and try to fix the situation - and while I know we're not perfect, there's no where on this Earth I'd rather be. We'll always be striving toward the more perfect union. This piece encourages me as I share that hope.
really exceptional my friend, thank you. you are one fine writer...
Thank You
Heartbreaking. Thank you
❤️
Thank you for telling the story!
This is so beautifully written; thank you for persevering to tell the story, even if it took decades. There is so much to be said for those who do the unglamorous jobs of cleaning up the aftermath of the most horrific crimes and incidents. (Of course, 9/11 was on a whole other level as far as incidents.) The piece is incredibly befitting of the respect and honor these workers and are due. They are the best of us.
These are many ways you could criticize the government regarding 9/11.
This isn't one.
Thank you.
I think the thing I appreciate the most is how you are able to express and hold the various experiences and viewpoints simultaneously. This isn't relativism. This is the human experience.
Michael, thank you for sharing this poignant exposé. I am grateful to know this.
That's very kind of you, Mike.
I have a picture from when I was working on disaster recovery for American Express. Part of our work brought us into Manhattan to do some migrations for them and I walked over to the site while they were honoring a fireman being pulled from the wreckage on March 12, 2022. The wrong side of the gasp witnessed by Michael can be better understood by Justine what was happening at the site well into 22.
That's interesting because one of my first things to do while the pit was being cleared, was visit the surrounding buildings, including the Amex building. I can remember walking up the escalators and using that elevation to look over at Ground Zero. Maybe we crossed paths that day.