How a convention-resort chain turned other people's money into a business model, why the Gaylord family isn't the villain anymore, and what the state of Colorado is quietly deciding this month
Hi. Rockies was the first built after the Marriott purchase. Construcion defects througtlout the conplex. Had to purxhase additional land in order to frustrate the invasion of development on all sides of the complex, which detract from the rustic setting. Looks nice. Not worth the hassle., nor the price.
Thanks Brownie for the compehensive summary on Gaylord Hotels and the financing schemes that are created in order to build them.
One positive aspect you did omit is the number of jobs that were created to plan, design, build and operate the properties which number in the thousands over the 6 Gaylord properties across the nation.
You're right that these hotels employ a lot of people, from the framers who built them to the folks working the front desk this morning.
Here's my problem with the jobs argument. Every business creates jobs. Jake Jabs created thousands of them selling furniture, and he did it without a dime of your tax money. The taco truck creates jobs. If "it creates jobs" were the test for a public subsidy, every business in Colorado would qualify, and we'd all be reaching into each other's pockets at once.
So the real question is never whether jobs got created. It's the three things the glossy study skips. Were they new jobs, or jobs moved across town? When Gaylord lands a convention by pulling it out of downtown Denver or the Broadmoor, the banquet and housekeeping work moves, it doesn't multiply.
Were the construction jobs permanent? Building jobs end when the building is done. And most of all, compared to what? That $1.3 billion doesn't vanish if the state says no. It builds roads, and road crews build roads. It stays in your pocket, and you spend it somewhere that hires somebody too. Those are the jobs nobody counts, because the money to make them got routed to a hotel first.
If the expansion really does create all those jobs and pays for itself, then Gaylord does not need my money to build it. Profitable projects get built every day without a subsidy. The ones that show up asking for hundreds of millions are telling you something about the math.
Thanks for reading the whole thing and pushing on it. That is exactly the kind of argument I want in the comments.
If you really want to boil your blood, look up the election that approved the Enhanced Taxing Area and the General Improvement District for Gaylord. Both elections had only one eligible voter - a representative of the corporation that owned the land.
Questions/Comments for the Commission: 1. How much of the existing Gaylord business has been independently demonstrated to be genuinely incremental to Colorado rather than displaced from other Colorado hotels?
2. Before approving any additional incentive, will the Commission publish a “but-for” analysis showing that the $300+ million expansion would not occur without the subsidy, along with the projected taxpayer return on every dollar of incentive?
3. What has the original Gaylord incentive produced so far—actual incentives/rebates received, actual incremental state and local tax revenue generated, and the resulting net return to taxpayers?
These are the three right questions. If the Commission answered them honestly, in public, this deal would answer itself. Let me take them in order, with what we actually know.
Incremental or displaced? Nobody has independently proven it, and that is the whole problem. The 2012 award was granted on the promise of net-new, out-of-state visitors. Fourteen years later, I have not seen an independent audit that separates the conventions Gaylord genuinely pulled into Colorado from the ones it pulled across town, out of downtown Denver, the Broadmoor, or a mountain lodge. Gaylord's own competitors say it is mostly the second kind. The burden of proving otherwise belongs to the people collecting the money, not to you and me.
The but-for analysis. This is the one that matters most, and the one they least want to run. "But-for" asks a simple thing: would this $300 million expansion happen anyway, without a nickel of subsidy? The evidence says yes. The owner is already reported as prepared to invest the money. The hotel runs 80% full and cleared $313 million last year. And we have been here before. When the state cut Gaylord's original request nearly in half, from $153 million down to $81.4 million, Gaylord built the thing anyway. The "we can't do it without the subsidy" claim already got called once, and it folded. So yes, make them publish the but-for analysis, and the projected return on every public dollar, before a single vote. If it were a good bet, they would be glad to show the math.
What has the first incentive actually produced? We have pieces of it, and the pieces are not comforting. The Denver Gazette pried loose the rebate numbers: the owner was already collecting more than $30 million a year in rebates by 2019, and the lifetime benefit is projected past $1.3 billion. What nobody has produced is a clean, independent accounting of the net return, the genuinely new tax revenue minus everything rebated, audited by someone who does not work for Gaylord. Ryman even told the state it could not document the guest spending that supposedly happens off the property. When the people getting the money admit they cannot prove the spillover, that is your answer.
Bring these three questions to the public meeting this month and make them answer on the record. That is how this gets stopped, or at least how it gets honest.
Thank you for writing them down better than most of the people who will be in that room.
I was just in Denver and on the way back to the airport asked “WTF is that?” Thanks for the knowledge.
Hi. Rockies was the first built after the Marriott purchase. Construcion defects througtlout the conplex. Had to purxhase additional land in order to frustrate the invasion of development on all sides of the complex, which detract from the rustic setting. Looks nice. Not worth the hassle., nor the price.
Thanks Brownie for the compehensive summary on Gaylord Hotels and the financing schemes that are created in order to build them.
One positive aspect you did omit is the number of jobs that were created to plan, design, build and operate the properties which number in the thousands over the 6 Gaylord properties across the nation.
You're right that these hotels employ a lot of people, from the framers who built them to the folks working the front desk this morning.
Here's my problem with the jobs argument. Every business creates jobs. Jake Jabs created thousands of them selling furniture, and he did it without a dime of your tax money. The taco truck creates jobs. If "it creates jobs" were the test for a public subsidy, every business in Colorado would qualify, and we'd all be reaching into each other's pockets at once.
So the real question is never whether jobs got created. It's the three things the glossy study skips. Were they new jobs, or jobs moved across town? When Gaylord lands a convention by pulling it out of downtown Denver or the Broadmoor, the banquet and housekeeping work moves, it doesn't multiply.
Were the construction jobs permanent? Building jobs end when the building is done. And most of all, compared to what? That $1.3 billion doesn't vanish if the state says no. It builds roads, and road crews build roads. It stays in your pocket, and you spend it somewhere that hires somebody too. Those are the jobs nobody counts, because the money to make them got routed to a hotel first.
If the expansion really does create all those jobs and pays for itself, then Gaylord does not need my money to build it. Profitable projects get built every day without a subsidy. The ones that show up asking for hundreds of millions are telling you something about the math.
Thanks for reading the whole thing and pushing on it. That is exactly the kind of argument I want in the comments.
If you really want to boil your blood, look up the election that approved the Enhanced Taxing Area and the General Improvement District for Gaylord. Both elections had only one eligible voter - a representative of the corporation that owned the land.
Did not know that. Will have to dig into it.
https://chatgpt.com/share/6aa404c9-d780-83e9-b634-6c9e2390a9aa
Thanks Brownie, I truly appreciate your take on Local & National politics, and goings on. Goober 2112
Questions/Comments for the Commission: 1. How much of the existing Gaylord business has been independently demonstrated to be genuinely incremental to Colorado rather than displaced from other Colorado hotels?
2. Before approving any additional incentive, will the Commission publish a “but-for” analysis showing that the $300+ million expansion would not occur without the subsidy, along with the projected taxpayer return on every dollar of incentive?
3. What has the original Gaylord incentive produced so far—actual incentives/rebates received, actual incremental state and local tax revenue generated, and the resulting net return to taxpayers?
These are the three right questions. If the Commission answered them honestly, in public, this deal would answer itself. Let me take them in order, with what we actually know.
Incremental or displaced? Nobody has independently proven it, and that is the whole problem. The 2012 award was granted on the promise of net-new, out-of-state visitors. Fourteen years later, I have not seen an independent audit that separates the conventions Gaylord genuinely pulled into Colorado from the ones it pulled across town, out of downtown Denver, the Broadmoor, or a mountain lodge. Gaylord's own competitors say it is mostly the second kind. The burden of proving otherwise belongs to the people collecting the money, not to you and me.
The but-for analysis. This is the one that matters most, and the one they least want to run. "But-for" asks a simple thing: would this $300 million expansion happen anyway, without a nickel of subsidy? The evidence says yes. The owner is already reported as prepared to invest the money. The hotel runs 80% full and cleared $313 million last year. And we have been here before. When the state cut Gaylord's original request nearly in half, from $153 million down to $81.4 million, Gaylord built the thing anyway. The "we can't do it without the subsidy" claim already got called once, and it folded. So yes, make them publish the but-for analysis, and the projected return on every public dollar, before a single vote. If it were a good bet, they would be glad to show the math.
What has the first incentive actually produced? We have pieces of it, and the pieces are not comforting. The Denver Gazette pried loose the rebate numbers: the owner was already collecting more than $30 million a year in rebates by 2019, and the lifetime benefit is projected past $1.3 billion. What nobody has produced is a clean, independent accounting of the net return, the genuinely new tax revenue minus everything rebated, audited by someone who does not work for Gaylord. Ryman even told the state it could not document the guest spending that supposedly happens off the property. When the people getting the money admit they cannot prove the spillover, that is your answer.
Bring these three questions to the public meeting this month and make them answer on the record. That is how this gets stopped, or at least how it gets honest.
Thank you for writing them down better than most of the people who will be in that room.