
Let’s get my conflict of interest out of the way first, because you deserve to know it. Colorado Public Radio (CPR) is my competition. So when I tell you the Colorado taxpayers like you just handed CPR $1.5 million to help build a gleaming new headquarters near downtown Denver — performance studios, a public café, conference rooms for community groups, the works — you are entitled to hear a little professional envy under my objections. Fair enough. Where’s my café? Where’s my $1.5 million build-out and my studio with the good acoustics? Nobody’s over here revitalizing my creative economy!
So set the envy aside. It’s real, sorta’, but it isn’t the argument. The argument would be identical if the check had gone to a station I’d never heard of, because the problem isn’t who got the money. It’s that the money exists at all — and what it’s quietly doing.
Start with what actually happened, because the phrase “tax credit” is doing an enormous amount of work in the press release. CPR was one of twelve recipients under Colorado’s Community Revitalization Tax Credit program, created by the legislature in 2024. It’s a $50 million pot — up to $10 million a year through the end of the decade — that hands out credits worth up to a quarter of a project’s cost, capped at three million each. CPR pulled $1.5 million. The Boulder Museum of Contemporary Art got the same. In an earlier round, a restored roadside tower in a town of 153 people got a slice. You get the picture: a state office deciding, project by project, which buildings deserve to exist.
Now here’s the part the coverage skated past. The credit is refundable. That one word changes everything. Refundable.
A tax credit, in the ordinary sense, lets you keep more of the money you owe. Handy — if you owe taxes. But CPR is a nonprofit. It pays little or no state income tax to begin with, so a regular credit would be worthless to them; there’s nothing to offset. A refundable credit is a different animal. When the credit is larger than the tax bill — and for a nonprofit, it always will be — the state pays you the difference. In cash. So peel away the accounting vocabulary and what Colorado actually did was write Colorado Public Radio a $1.5 million check and run it through the Department of Revenue so it wouldn’t look like one.
That’s the whole ballgame for the defense that goes, “Relax, it’s a tax credit, not government spending.” It is spending. It is a subsidy. The tax code is just the envelope it arrived in.
Which brings us to the part that should make even CPR’s most loyal listeners tilt their heads. Here’s the backdrop: the federal money is gone. Congress clawed back the funding for the Corporation for Public Broadcasting — the pipeline that bankrolled NPR, PBS, and their local stations for nearly sixty years — and this past January, CPB filed its dissolution papers and switched off the lights. So public radio is hunting for new revenue. Fair enough; everybody’s got to keep the transmitter on.
But rewind a few months before that, to when the administration first moved to defund public broadcasting as payback for coverage it disliked. NPR and three Colorado stations — Colorado Public Radio among them — took the President to federal court. And they won. This past March, a judge struck the order down as unconstitutional retaliation: viewpoint discrimination wearing a budget decision’s clothes. NPR’s chief executive distilled the win into a sentence I’d happily frame on my wall: “the government cannot use funding as a lever to influence or penalize the press.” A principle, she pointedly added, that protects the local newsroom every bit as much as the national network.
Read that sentence again, because CPR walked straight into it. The principle they won on is that government money must never become a lever over the press. But a lever only works if there’s something to pull on — the government cannot weaponize a check you never cashed. And no newsroom in America understands this more intimately than CPR, because a President just tried to pull that exact lever, and they spent the better part of a year in court prying his fingers off it. Lesson learned, you’d think. Instead, months later, they walked over to a different government — the State of Colorado, whose statehouse their own reporters cover every single day — and asked it to hand them a fresh lever. And not the Congressionally-appropriated money, buffered through a private corporation, that CPR argued was dangerous even with all that insulation. A direct, discretionary check from an executive-branch agency that answers to the Governor. If the federal subsidy was a loaded lever, this is the same lever with the safety off.
To their credit, CPR didn’t dodge the conflict question. Their own editor said the company does business with the government “as any business would,” and that it’s walled off from the newsroom. A journalism professor up in Boulder likened it to taking a grant from the Knight Foundation, or to the way European democracies fund the press. And honestly? On the surface, that’s not crazy. Newsrooms take outside money all the time. A firewall between the business side and the reporters is real, and it mostly, usually works?
Yes, it works — against the wrong threat. A foundation can’t tax you. It can’t subpoena you, regulate you, license your spectrum, or sit in judgment of your next application. And it is never the subject of your beat. The state is all of those things at once. It is simultaneously CPR’s benefactor and CPR’s permanent assignment. A firewall can cure the appearance of a gift from a stranger. It cannot cure a structural entanglement with the most powerful institution your reporters are supposed to hold to account. That’s not a slur on anyone’s ethics. It’s just the geometry of the thing. CPR is going to hold the powerful to account, when the powerful are the ones funding them?
And notice the tell in that defense: “as any business would.” Yes. Precisely. CPR is a business — a private nonprofit corporation that competes for attention, sells sponsorships, and puts up its buildings like the rest of us. I have no quarrel with any of that. My only ask is that it pick a lane. You are welcome to be a business. You are welcome to wear the halo of public service. You are not entitled to both at once — and you are certainly not entitled to bill the taxpayer for the second while operating as the first.
That lane problem gets sharper still when you look at what kind of program this actually is. It isn’t a generic economic-development fund. It’s the Creative Industry Community Revitalization Tax Credit, run by Colorado Creative Industries — which is the old Colorado Council on the Arts wearing a new name tag, rebranded in 2010 and still handing out National Endowment for the Arts dollars. By statute, the program funds buildings that advance the creative industries. That’s the only door in. To walk through it, you have to be an arts-and-culture enterprise — and CPR walked through it.
A fair-minded person will note that broadcasting has always been counted in the “creative economy,” under the state’s “film and media” heading. True enough — and that concession is precisely the point. For the past year, whenever the subject was federal money or public trust, CPR was a journalism institution: the fourth estate, the free press, the very thing the First Amendment was written to shield. That’s the identity it carried into federal court. Now, with an arts subsidy on the table, CPR is a creative-industries business, slotted into the same entertainment-sector column as the theater troupes and the design studios. It cannot be both on command. The First Amendment protects journalism; it does not come with a standing line of credit at the state’s culture budget.
Here’s the thing that gets lost in the applause. The state’s own pitch for this program brags that arts and culture pump $20 billion a year into Colorado’s economy and support 120,000 jobs. That’s actually an argument against the check, not for it. You do not put a thriving twenty-billion-dollar sector on life support. If the creative economy is that robust — and it is — then the market is already funding it, which is exactly what markets are for. The subsidy isn’t rescuing a struggling art form. It’s picking who gets a nicer building.
I’ll even take CPR’s CEO at his word when he promises the newsroom’s coverage will never bend to “fear or favor.” I don’t doubt his sincerity for a second. But sincerity was never the issue. Independence isn’t something a newsroom gets to assert about itself; it’s something the audience has to be able to see. And an audience watching a station cash checks from the government that station covers has every reason to wonder — not because the reporters are compromised, but because the arrangement itself is what gives a reasonable person pause. You can’t sincerity your way out of an appearance problem. The only real cure is not to create it in the first place.
So no, I’m not really wondering where my new studio is. I know where it is. It’s the one I built myself at home, the one my company, iHeartMedia, built with money from sponsors and shareholders who wouldn’t dream of editing me. That’s not a hardship to complain about. That’s the whole point. Turns out independence was for sale after all.
I just didn’t expect public radio to be first in line to buy its way out of independence. Be careful what you listen to.


In the right hands this is a rising tide. In the wrong hands it is money laundering.
Hmmm. Budget deficit. Colo Public Broadcasting is not an emergency broadcast station. Another political hack agency., codename NGO. Wonder which budgetary line entry is being reallocated to cover this post-budget expenditure?