It was hot out this morning, and you knew it was going to be. So did the Colorado Department of Transportation. Up on one of those big overhead message boards on the interstate — the ones that usually tell you to buckle up, or that speeding kills, or that a DUI runs you nine grand — the message today read: “Ozone Alert Today. Take One Less Trip.”
Take one less trip. And I had a small, uncharitable thought, which was that I already know what my day looks like, it includes an errand I didn’t even have last night, and I am not turning the car around. I’d also bet the mortgage that nobody else reading that sign at seventy miles an hour rerouted their day either. Everyone on that highway is, definitionally, already on the highway. That train has left the station.
I could’ve left it there — filed it under harmless nanny-state noise and gone about my day. But I got curious, because that little sign makes two claims. One: that it changes what you do. Two: that what you do changes the ozone. It turns out there’s real, peer-reviewed science on both. And on both counts, the sign doesn’t just come up short. It comes up backwards.
Count one: the sign may be making the road more dangerous
Set the ozone aside for a second and think about the whole category of these electronic message boards — the ones engineered to grab your attention and nudge your behavior.
In 2022, two economists — Jonathan Hall at the University of Toronto and Joshua Madsen at the University of Minnesota — published a study in Science, one of the two most prestigious peer-reviewed journals on the planet. Not a think tank, not an advocacy shop. Science. They looked at Texas, which had accidentally run a near-perfect experiment: the state posted its running annual traffic-death count on message boards, but only one week out of every month. Same signs, same roads, same drivers. On, off, on, off.
So Hall and Madsen pulled every crash in Texas over eight years — 844,939 of them — and compared the weeks the death-toll message was up against the weeks it was down, matched by hour and day of week, controlling for weather and holidays. (The study is here; a plain-English write-up from Minnesota’s Center for Transportation Studies is here.)
The finding: in the stretch of road right after the signs, crashes went up when the message was showing. On the roughly six miles following the boards, crashes rose 4.5 percent during display weeks. To put that in terms you can feel, the researchers said the effect was about the same as raising the speed limit three to five miles an hour. That is the safety cost of a safety message.
And the details are what tell you it’s real. The bigger the number on the sign, the worse the effect — the most extra crashes came in January, when the board displayed the full prior-year total, the scariest figure. It got worse exactly where drivers were already loaded up: heavy traffic, complex interchanges, stretches with multiple signs. And it showed up as multi-vehicle crashes, not single-vehicle ones — the fingerprint of a distracted driver drifting half a lane into the car beside him rather than sailing off into a ditch.
The authors had a phrase I love: the messages can be too salient. So attention-grabbing that they crowd out the one thing you actually need to be doing, which is driving the car. Your attention is a budget, not an infinite resource, and every word on that board is a withdrawal.
Now, in fairness — and you’re smart enough to catch me if I skip this — that study was about death-toll signs, the deliberately alarming kind. An ozone advisory is not a body count, and I’m not going to tell you “Take One Less Trip” is killing anyone. That’s not the claim.
The claim is narrower and it holds: any sign that isn’t telling you something you need in order to drive — a curve, a wreck ahead, ice on the bridge — is a tax on your attention that buys you nothing back. A seatbelt reminder at least points to an action you can take in that car, right now. A lecture about your travel habits, read at highway speed by someone whose day is already locked in, is pure cost with nothing on the other side of the ledger. And as we’re about to see, there really is nothing on the other side.
Count two: your one trip cannot move the ozone
Here’s the thing most people don’t know about ozone, and it changes the whole picture. Ground-level ozone doesn’t come out of your tailpipe. You don’t emit it. It gets cooked — formed when two ingredients, nitrogen oxides and volatile organic compounds, bake together in hot sunlight. That’s why it’s a summer problem, and why the sign was up on a hot day.
So the real question isn’t how much people are driving. It’s where the ingredients come from. And on the Front Range, the answer will surprise you, because mostly it isn’t your car.
Start with the background. On an average summer day here, about 58 of our parts-per-billion of ozone is already baked in before anyone starts a car — it either blew in from elsewhere or it’s left over from ozone cooked the day before. The federal limit is 70. Sit with that: roughly 58 of our allowable 70 is spoken for at dawn. That background is wildfires, emissions from trees and plants, lightning, pollution drifting in from other countries, even ozone sinking down out of the stratosphere. (CIRES, the CU-Boulder environmental research institute, walks through the accounting here; the EPA’s Front Range background breakdown is here.) You cannot idle your engine less and fix the stratosphere. It is not on the menu.
Then the local stuff. Up in the northern part of the range — Boulder toward Fort Collins — the dominant local driver isn’t cars at all; it’s oil and gas operations out in the Wattenberg field. One study of high-ozone days near Boulder found that transport from the oil-and-gas areas accounted for about 65 percent of the elevated ozone, while the entire Denver urban corridor — all of us, all our cars — accounted for about nine. (That research is summarized here.)
And here’s the most car-unfriendly number I could find — the one that gives the sign every possible benefit of the doubt. The big FRAPPÉ field study, the one our own state legislature cites, found that on bad ozone days, motor vehicles and oil-and-gas each contribute somewhere around 30 to 40 percent of the local ozone, with the rest coming from power plants, industry, and the airport. (NCAR’s summary is here.) But read “motor vehicles” carefully. That’s the entire regional fleet — every commuter, every semi, every delivery van and bus, all of it, all day, added together. That whole mountain of metal is a third of the local piece, which is itself a slice of a total that’s mostly background.
So where does your one skipped trip land in that? It doesn’t. It’s a rounding error inside a rounding error inside a number that’s mostly not even from around here. No ozone monitor in Colorado will ever twitch because I skipped a run to the hardware store. And — here’s the tell — the people who wrote the sign know it.
How do I know they know? Because the state’s own campaign, Simple Steps. Better Air. — the program that sign is quietly steering you toward — doesn’t ask you to stop driving. It asks you to skip two car trips a week. Two. And it doesn’t promise that’ll fix anything; it calls it “doing your part.” That’s the vocabulary of a gesture, not a result. If skipping trips actually moved the needle, they’d ask for a lot more than two a week and they’d tell you exactly what you’d get for it. They ask for almost nothing because almost nothing is what it does.
For the record, this wasn’t even a severe day. The Ozone Action Day Alert in effect this morning had a high ozone reading of 77 on the Air Quality Index — squarely “Moderate,” below the “unhealthy for sensitive groups” line. The urgency of the signage and the reality of the air were not on speaking terms.
So am I supposed to feel guilty? No. The guilt is the product.
Put the two halves together and look at what that sign actually is. It belongs to a category that the best evidence we have says can make the road less safe — and it’s asking you to take an action that the best evidence we have says will not measurably change the thing it names. A safety sign that undercuts safety, drafted into a fight where your personal contribution is a rounding error. And you paid for the sign, and you paid for the study that could have warned them, and you’ll pay for the next sign too.
I’m not even mad about the ozone. I’ll confess I sort of like the smell of it — that sharp, clean, after-the-storm smell. (I like the smell of jet fuel, too, so don’t seat my nose on the jury.) My point is bigger than one sign on one hot morning.
This is what a certain kind of government does instead of governing. It can’t lower the background ozone. It isn’t going to have the hard fight over the oil-and-gas fields, because that fight is hard and has constituents on both sides. So it does the one thing that’s easy and free and demands nothing of anyone in charge: it puts up a sign, shifts the responsibility onto you, and lets you feel a little bad for driving to work. It’s a mood ring bolted to a gantry. It lights up, tells you how you’re supposed to feel, and does precisely nothing to the air.
Don’t feel guilty. Feeling guilty was the whole point. Take the trip.


I continue to be impressed by the homework you do for these articles Michael. Thank you for the enlightenment as always!
Government overreach is making things worse. It's just another example of micromanagement in our lives.