CORRECTION — September 18, 2026
I originally called this Amendment 84. It’s Amendment 83.
The number I used came from coverage published before the Secretary of State certified the ballot on September 4. I should have rechecked it against the certified list instead of carrying it forward. And it wasn’t a harmless slip. Amendment 84 is a real and separate measure on the same ballot, mail-ballot voter ID, so the wrong number aimed you at the wrong fight.
A reader caught it. I fixed it throughout. The whole premise of this page is that you can check my work, so when you catch me, I don’t quietly scrub it. I say thank you and I fix it in daylight. Everything below now reads Amendment 83, the constitutional right to hunt and fish.
This morning I discussed Amendment 83, the “Constitutional Right to Hunt & Fish.” This is from the program, and I hope you will read it closely and understand that I support hunting and fishing, and have serious doubts about Amendment 83, but will vote for it anyway. Here is why. It started with a post on Facebook that sent me down the proverbial rabbit hole.
Chris Rourke posts a question. Four words. Who is Eric Washburn? Then answers the question. Washburn is the guy who brought you wolves, the man behind a program where wolves keep dying, and now he wants to take away your right to hunt and fish. Don’t let him fool you. The replies pile on. He’s in bed with the environmentalists. He’s spinning you with fear. They’re the whole reason this amendment has got to pass.
It’s a good post. Angry, clean, and it makes you want to grab the pitchforks and torches. I felt the pull too. I’ve shared posts like that before I read the thing underneath it. Admit it. You probably have, too.
I pulled the thread on the cuff of this story and I’ll tell you up front. I’m voting yes on Amendment 83. And no, I don’t trust it.
I don’t trust the money behind it. I don’t trust the people running it. I think there’s a real chance this amendment backfires. So here is why I’m voting yes on something I half expect to blow up in our faces, and why I’m holding my nose and voting yes anyway.
If you disagree with any of my reasons, then tell me so in the comments. But please, explain why.
Start with what’s honest about this proposal
Amendment 83 inserts a right to hunt and fish into the Colorado Constitution. Most of you hear that and nod, yes, because of course we believe we have a right to hunt and fish. So do I. The reason isn’t bloodlust. It’s distrust. You’ve watched wildlife policy in this state get made by people who have never sat in a cold blind at 5:00 a.m. or gutted an elk with their hands going numb. You look at Denver and the wildlife commission and you don’t see yourself being represented in that room. So you want a lock on the door no city-slicker can pick. That distrust is earned. I share it.
I hunt. I fish. I’ve done both my whole life. But when I go after this amendment, I’m going after the words in it and the men behind it. The hunt itself I’ll defend all day.
What the amendment says
A right to hunt and fish by “traditional methods.” Hunting and fishing named the “preferred” way to manage wildlife. The state may regulate only when it’s necessary for science, for public safety, or for the future of the sport. It needs 55% to pass. Wolves and lynx get carved out because they’re federally protected.
Two phrases to hold onto. Traditional methods. Preferred method. Those aren’t my words. They’re the words that go into our Constitution and stay there.
I say follow the money
Go to the campaign’s website, savethehuntcolorado.com. Pretty pictures, a podcast, a donate button. What you will not find anywhere on it is who’s paying for this campaign.
So go to the state, because in Colorado the committee running a ballot measure must disclose its funders. Bingo. There it is. The committee is the T. Roosevelt Conservation Alliance, tied to a Wisconsin outfit called the International Order of Theodore Roosevelt. The filings show about $1.34 million raised and roughly $1.5 million spent, most of it for paid signature gatherers. Dan Gates and his Colorado group are the local face. The money is from Wisconsin.
And the man they brought in to run it tells you nearly everything. His name is Luke Hilgemann. Before this, he was the chief executive of Americans for Prosperity, the flagship of the Koch political network. Before that he ran Wisconsin’s Americans for Prosperity and fought transit and streetcars as part of what the press out there called the Koch agenda. Then he ran a group called Hunter Nation.
Here’s the part that caused me to do a double take. In 2021, Hilgemann and Hunter Nation went to court to force Wisconsin to hold a wolf hunt the minute wolves lost federal protection. They won a court order. The hunt that followed blew past the state’s own quota. Hundreds of wolves killed in under 3 days. That hunt was condemned across the country. That’s the résumé of the outfit writing words into our Constitution. Out-of-state money, a Koch operative running the show, and a wolf hunt that ran off the rails under his watch.
These groups want the lawsuits
Hilgemann doesn’t hide the strategy. He brags about it. He told a hunting magazine these amendments are about being “on offense,” and that their real power “lies in the case law they create,” the “precedent-setting barriers.”
Go back and read that paragraph again.
The man running the campaign says the point of the amendment is to create lawsuits. To build precedent in a courtroom. The vagueness in the wording “traditional methods” is not a mistake in the drafting. It’s the product. If they offered a clean, tight amendment with wording that specifically and scientifically protected hunting but did not generate lawsuits, well, that amendment would be no use to him. Why? Because the lawsuits are the whole business.
The homeless industrial complex, wearing camouflage
I’ve spent a lot of hours taking apart the homeless industrial complex. The machine that takes a real problem, homelessness, and cultivates it instead of solving it. Name the crisis, sell the fix, the fix funds the outfit, the outfit needs the crisis, so the crisis never ends. I look at this hunting amendment and I see the same machine in hunter orange and camo.
The threat to hunting is real. That’s not the con. Activists ran a measure to make hunting and fishing criminal acts in Oregon. Real people really tried it. And a real, chronic, frightening threat is exactly what a machine like this feeds on, because you can’t cultivate a problem that isn’t there. These groups take a genuine fear, and instead of eliminating the fear, they build a permanent campaign on top of it. Name the threat, sell the amendment, the amendment breeds the lawsuits, the lawsuits need the lawyers, the lawyers cost the money, so you raise the money off the threat, and the threat can never be allowed to die, because the day it dies the checks stop flowing to feed the new industrial complex.
Same play as the homeless racket. Different mascot. And the mascot out front, the sympathetic face on the poster, is the ordinary Colorado hunter who just wants his hunting season or fishing license. He doesn’t get durable protection. The outfit gets its year funded either way.
The villain the post sold you
Go back to that Facebook post, because it rests on one man being the villain, I did my background check. Eric Washburn is a fifth-generation Coloradan out of Steamboat Springs. He’s a big-game hunter. He shoots what you shoot. And yes, in 2020 he was the hunter the wolf campaign put out front, so “the guy who brought you wolves” is close enough to true, and rural Colorado has every right to be sore about it.
But here’s another double take I took.
Washburn is not anti-hunting. He’s a hunter telling you this amendment is dangerous to hunting. We can be furious at him about wolves and still have to answer the question he’s raising, because he raises it as one of us.
And let me tell you something the Facebook post left out. Washburn isn’t the only no vote. The animal-rights crowd, Humane World for Animals, is against 83 too, but for the opposite reason. They want it dead because it protects hunting. He wants it dead because he thinks it protects hunting badly. Same vote, opposite hearts. I don’t share the animal-rights goal, not for a second. My worry is the hunter’s worry, that we’re about to shoot ourselves in the foot with our own Constitution. And the thread’s claim that Washburn is “in bed” with an environmental activist named Erik Molvar? I went looking, couldn’t prove it, and won’t say it. Bring me the proof and I’ll correct the record.
The two words, and the collision
Here’s the warning, and it’s the heart of the thing. Two words. Traditional methods. Nobody defined them. Anywhere.
Colorado already answered the question of banned methods, and Colorado voters did it themselves. And they wrote it straight into the Constitution. Article 18, Section 12b. In 1996, voters banned the leghold trap, the body-gripping trap, the snare, and poison. That ban has sat in our Constitution for thirty years.
But watch closely. Amendment 83 drops a second line into that same Constitution, a right to hunt by “traditional methods.” Two provisions, one document, pointing dead opposite. One says the leghold trap and the snare are banned. The other says traditional methods are a protected right. A leghold trap is about as traditional as it gets. Which one wins? Nobody knows until a judge says so. The speed bump I want this to be, and the boomerang I fear it will be, are the same object. It’s one gamble, and I know that going in.
The part that cuts against my own vote
What’s the argument against my vote for this amendment? In the other states that already did this, these amendments have mostly done nothing in a courtroom. When a hunter in North Carolina tried to use his state’s version to knock out a hunting restriction (*Oates v. Berger*), the court shrugged, applied the lowest standard of review there is, and sided with the regulators. So there’s a real chance Amendment 83 is a painted line. A speed bump that isn’t a bump at all. It might not slow the state down one inch. Do you think Phil Weiser will let this speed bump stop what Jared Polis has started?
And there’s the other chance, that some judge reads those two words wide and blows a hole in the trap ban we already passed. It might do nothing. It might do damage. The one thing it will not do is the clean, reliable job the campaign is selling. You’re rolling dice, and so am I.
So why yes
One reason. Who’s about to hold the pen.
Everyone in this state expects Phil Weiser to be our next governor. And the governor appoints the Wildlife Commission, the same commission hunters currently are accusing Governor Polis of stacking against them. The ballot box already did its job once. In 2024, voters beat the worst anti-hunting measure, the mountain-lion hunting ban, 55 to 45, and they did it without any amendment at all.
But here’s what the ballot box cannot reach. It cannot stop a stacked commission from squeezing you one regulation at a time, in a hearing room, where you never get a vote. That’s the door I want something across. A weak bar, maybe. One the Wisconsin machine profits from every time I mention it. One a judge might lean on and snap. I want it there anyway, because the alternative is an open door and a governor with the pen.
What I’m telling you, and what I’m not
This amendment is poorly worded. On purpose. The people behind it are not all on your side, and some are running a racket wearing that hunter orange and camo. And I can’t promise you it works, because it might not. What I can tell you is this. In a state headed where this one is headed, with the man everyone expects to be our next governor holding the appointment pen, I would rather have a speed bump that might not hold than no speed bump at all.
So I’m voting yes. And I feel a little used doing it, because I know whose pocket it fills. That bad taste is the honest price of the vote, and I’m paying it with my eyes open.
There is a tell inside the tell
They named this outfit after Theodore Roosevelt. Roosevelt was a hunter. He was also the man who looked at unregulated hunting, the market gunning that wiped out the game, and built the whole system of science and seasons and limits to stop it. That’s why we have elk to hunt today. Putting his name on an amendment built to hamstring regulation and manufacture lawsuits takes Roosevelt’s rifle and buries the rest of him. He spent his life fencing in the very word these folks want to carve loose in your Constitution.
That’s my vote. Yes on 83, eyes open and nose held. You weigh the same facts and land where your own conscience puts you. I’ll respect it either way.
Sourcing and Verification
I keep verified fact, attributed claim, and my own inference separate, and I don’t ask you to take my word for anything you can check yourself.
What it is and does. Amendment 83 began as citizen Initiative 302, needs 55 percent, and writes a right to hunt and fish “by traditional methods” into the Colorado Constitution, names hunting and fishing the “preferred method” of managing wildlife, allows regulation only for science, public safety, or the future of the sport, and excludes federally protected species. Signature counts from Complete Colorado; the text and both sides from Colorado Newsline, KUNC, and Westword.
The money. The registered issue committee is the T. Roosevelt Conservation Alliance, tied to the Wisconsin-based International Order of Theodore Roosevelt and its arm T. Roosevelt Action; roughly $1.34 million raised and $1.5 million spent, mostly on paid signature-gathering, with Colorado support from Coloradans for Responsible Wildlife Management, Howl for Wildlife, and the 76 Group. See American Hunter and Colorado Politics. The campaign website carries no funder disclosure; Colorado issue committees must file donors with the Secretary of State.
Luke Hilgemann and the group. Former CEO of Americans for Prosperity and former Wisconsin AFP director (Urban Milwaukee). The International Order of Theodore Roosevelt was launched in April 2022 and continues the former Shikar Safari Club fundraiser; its founding CEO was former U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service director Aurelia Skipwith Giacometto (PR Newswire). Hunter Nation’s 2021 suit forcing Wisconsin’s wolf hunt: Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty. The February 2021 hunt’s overkill (widely reported near 218 wolves against a quota around 119) comes from contemporaneous reporting; I state it as “hundreds, well past the quota.” This is one figure I’m still nailing down precisely.
“The case law they create.” Hilgemann’s own words, in Outdoor Life.
The litigation record. Sparse. In *Oates v. Berger*, the North Carolina Court of Appeals applied rational-basis review and upheld hunting restrictions against a right-to-hunt challenge (Carolina Journal). An industry analysis notes “very few lawsuits” citing these amendments so far (The Outdoor Wire). Florida’s post-Amendment-2 bear-hunt litigation is about population science, not the amendment (WUWF). So my forecast that 83 invites litigation is an inference, not a settled fact, and the record so far suggests courts read these cases narrowly.
The Florida parallel. Florida’s 2024 Amendment 2 used the same “traditional methods” and “preferred means” language, and opponents raised the identical collision with Florida’s 1994 constitutional gill-net ban (Florida Phoenix).
The 1996 ban. Amendment 14, now Article XVIII, Section 12b of the Colorado Constitution: leghold traps, body-gripping traps, snares, and poison, with limited exceptions (Animal Legal & Historical Center).
The prior votes. The 2020 wolf reintroduction passed by about 20,000 votes; the 2024 ban on hunting mountain lions, bobcats, and lynx failed 55.5 to 44.5 (Colorado Sun 2020, Colorado Sun 2024).
The politics. Phil Weiser is the Democratic nominee for governor and the widely expected winner; he has not endorsed Amendment 83 and calls himself “always cautious about using constitutional amendments to create statewide policy” (Colorado Sun). The governor appoints the Parks and Wildlife Commission, which hunting groups have accused Governor Polis of stacking against them (Colorado Sun).
My inference, labeled as mine. That the “traditional methods” language invites litigation, that the operation is cultivating a real threat for perpetual funding, and that a Weiser-appointed commission is the danger worth hedging against, are my reads of the evidence, not settled facts. Reasonable hunters land elsewhere. Corrections and documents are welcome at michaelbrown@iheartmedia.com.



Good analysis. It’s helpful to know the whole story behind a ballot measure. I too will vote for it.
It is a shame that almost every amendment these days has hidden agendas. I think it is one reason that keeps some people from voting. You read the guides that say, a yes vote means … and a no vote means…. yet you still have no idea which way you want to vote.