Most conservatives are missing the backstory about how Zohran Mamdani became mayor of New York City, how the chairman of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus lost his primary last month, and how Colorado’s Diana DeGette, first elected when Bill Clinton was in his first term, was fired by Denver Democrats last month and replaced by a 29-year-old Democratic Socialists of America organizer named Melat Kiros.
The story is not that some shadowy socialist billionaire wrote a check. The story is that New York City taxpayers wrote a very large check. And they did it eight bucks at a time.
Here is how it works. New York City runs what is called a small-donor matching program. If you are a New York City resident and you give a qualifying candidate 250 dollars, the city kicks in eight taxpayer dollars for every one of yours on that first 250. Your 250 becomes 2,250 in the candidate’s campaign account. One donation becomes nine. The program has existed since 1988. On paper it is politically neutral. Any qualifying candidate can use it.
Andrew Cuomo used it. Curtis Sliwa used it. Zohran Mamdani used it too. And Mamdani used it better than anyone in the history of American municipal politics.
By the general election last November, Mamdani’s campaign had about 17 million dollars available. Roughly 13 million of it was taxpayer money. Cuomo’s campaign had about 14 million, of which 8 million was taxpayer money. About 90 percent of Mamdani’s donors gave under $250, exactly the profile the matching system rewards. He didn’t just win. He was subsidized to win, at scale, by a city government whose police, housing, and business climate he had promised to fundamentally transform.
The people who designed New York City’s matching program in 1988 had a subversive objective. They claimed campaigns for city office were becoming captive to wealthy donors and special interests. The idea was to amplify the voice of ordinary residents, to make it possible for a schoolteacher or a small business owner to launch a credible campaign without begging a real estate developer for a $5,000 check. The Brennan Center supports the program. So-called reform groups support it. Republicans on the New York City Campaign Finance Board have generally supported it. It is not, on its face, a socialist scheme. They claim it is a good-government idea about broadening participation.
I take the claim seriously. The worry about wealthy donors buying influence is a concern that a lot of Americans share across the political spectrum. But there worry does not make their solution legitimate. And this particular solution, taxpayer-financed campaigns, is wrong not just because of what it produces on the ground. It is wrong on principle. Let me tell you what I actually believe about campaign finance, because it is out of step with a lot of the reform conversation.
I believe money in politics is speech. The Supreme Court said so in Buckley v. Valeo back in 1976 and Buckley was right. If I want to support a candidate I believe in, I ought to be able to write that candidate a check for whatever amount I choose, so long as the campaign discloses every dollar of it publicly. That is the conservative answer to worries about big money in elections. Sunshine, not silence. Repeal the McCain-Feingold contribution caps. Let Americans give what they want to the candidates they actually support. And require every campaign to disclose every donor and every dollar in daylight.
Public financing is the constitutional problem in reverse. If forced silence is bad, and it is, forced sponsorship is worse. When my tax dollars, taken from me by a taxing authority I cannot opt out of, are handed to a campaign whose platform I find abhorrent, the government has compelled me to subsidize political speech I oppose. That is not campaign finance reform. That is the First Amendment violated in the other direction. It says that the state has decided which speech is worth funding, and we, the taxpayers, will fund it whether we agree with it or not.
Now, with that principle stated plainly, look at what this particular mechanism actually does on the street. A neutral mechanism can produce a wildly unbalanced result if one faction is better organized to exploit it than the others are. The matching system multiplies small donations. So it inevitably benefits the political organization best positioned to manufacture thousands of small, qualifying, ideologically motivated donations on command. That organization is not the Democratic National Committee, which runs on big checks, bundlers, and committee transfers. It is the Democratic Socialists of America, whose entire financial culture is built on recurring monthly dues paid by true believers.
And this is where the picture starts to look very familiar to anyone who has watched the homelessness industrial complex operate here in Colorado.
Follow the flywheel. On July 4 of this year, DSA announced that it had crossed 120,000 dues-paying members, making it the largest socialist organization in American history. Its total national revenue in a good year runs about 6 million dollars. To put that in perspective, the Democratic National Committee alone raised somewhere around 684 million dollars in the last election cycle. The DNC out-raises DSA by better than a hundred to one. And yet DSA is the one winning primaries.
How? Membership dues. Nearly 90 percent of DSA’s national revenue comes from dues, and dues are a subscription. Every new member is a recurring monthly payment. In New York City, national DSA sends 20 percent of monthly dues back to the local chapter, which also collects its own separate local dues on top of that. National growth automatically finances local electoral infrastructure. Offices. Literature. Technology. Staff. Year-round. In the exact neighborhoods where the next primary challenge is going to be mounted.
Then comes the volunteer army. Mamdani’s primary operation deployed over 50,000 volunteers who knocked on 1.5 million doors and made about 2 million phone calls. By the general election, that number was 100,000 unique volunteers and roughly 3 million doors. That labor appears on no campaign finance report anywhere. It is the invisible half of the operation. And political science tells us it works. The famous Yale field experiment by Gerber and Green established a quarter century ago that door-to-door canvassing substantially increases turnout, while phone calls barely move the needle. DSA read the literature and built its doctrine around it.
The results are now a pattern. In 2018, Joe Crowley, the number-four Democrat in the House, outspent Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez 18 to 1 and lost his primary. AOC summarized it in seven words. “We beat a machine with a movement.”
Last month, on June 23, it happened again on a bigger stage. In New York, Congressman Dan Goldman spent about 8.1 million dollars defending his seat, including more than 2 million dollars in personal loans, and lost to Brad Lander, who spent 1.75 million. Congressman Adriano Espaillat, chairman of the Congressional Hispanic Caucus, was outspent roughly 3 to 1 by Darializa Avila Chevalier, a 32-year-old worker at a public defender’s office and a DSA member. Espaillat lost too. And right here in Colorado, 15-term Congresswoman Diana DeGette, who had held Denver’s First District since 1997, lost her primary to Melat Kiros. Kiros is a DSA endorsee. She is 29 years old. She had never run for office before.
Now here is the part that ought to stop conservative readers cold.
The DSA endorsement criteria adopted after its 2025 national convention require that candidates commit to uphold the DSA platform, grow their local chapters, recruit new members, caucus with other DSA officeholders, and, and I quote, “regard themselves as socialist organizers first, and legislators second.”
Read that again. Voters in these districts believe they are electing a representative. DSA believes it is deploying an organizer who happens to hold office. Campaign finance filings confirm the arrangement. Mamdani’s mayoral campaign paid the New York City DSA chapter over $33,000 for coordinated texting and email work. That is the candidate paying the movement for access to the movement’s own mobilization list. A party within a party is not a metaphor here. It is an org chart.
And that brings me back to the analogy.
For years on my radio program I have talked about the homelessness industrial complex. A nonprofit gets taxpayer money to serve the homeless. It uses that money to hire staff, expand programs, and grow an operation. That larger operation then lobbies for more taxpayer money, which funds more staff, which lobbies for still more money. The homeless problem does not get solved, because solving it would end the funding. The problem becomes the product.
The political industrial complex works the same way. Taxpayers in New York City finance a candidate’s campaign through the matching program. The winning candidate hires movement staff, contracts with the movement’s own texting and email operation, and uses the office as a recruiting platform for the next member drive. More members produce more dues, which finance more local infrastructure, which trains more volunteers, who elect more candidates, who tap more taxpayer matching funds. NYC DSA co-chair Gustavo Gordillo put it very cleanly after Mamdani’s general election win: “they have money, but we have power.” He was right. And the taxpayers of New York City are helping to pay for that power.
Public financing of political campaigns is wrong. Always. On principle. It was wrong when it was proposed as a good-government reform back in 1988, and it is wrong now that we can see with our own eyes exactly what it produces. Every dollar of the roughly $13 million that New York City taxpayers were forced to hand Zohran Mamdani’s campaign was a dollar taken by a taxing authority from residents who may have opposed everything he stood for, and then used to elect him anyway. That is not democracy amplified. That is dissent taxed. It is the government picking a side in a political fight and billing the losing side for the winner’s campaign materials.
The right answer to concerns about money in politics is not more government. It is less government. Repeal the McCain-Feingold contribution limits. Let Americans give what they choose to the candidates they actually believe in. Require full disclosure of every dollar. Sunlight, not subsidy. Speech, not conscription. That is a system consistent with the First Amendment. What New York City has is not.
Republicans who comfort themselves with fundraising totals are reading the wrong ledger anyway. A 6-million-dollar national organization is assembling federal, state, and local power that a 684-million-dollar party committee cannot seem to stop. And municipal taxpayers are helping to bankroll it. If we do not understand how the machine actually works, we cannot answer it. And if we cannot answer it, we should not be surprised when it keeps winning our elections with our own money.



Sheesh! American ingenuity being mobilized to upend our societal way of life. Agree with your proposed remedy, although there are additional actions necessary. Observed that conservatives might be a Colorado frog in a pot of water. Sadness.