There’s a number going around this week, and it sounds like a moral indictment. The Massachusetts Institute of Technology maintains something called the Living Wage Calculator, and my local morning shows have been running with its findings: here is what it costs to actually live, here is the wage a family would need to cover it, and — the unspoken close — isn’t it a scandal that nobody is requiring employers to pay it?
Let’s take that seriously, because the people making the argument are not stupid and the underlying data is not junk. But I also want to walk you through why the conclusion everyone is gliding toward — just mandate the living wage — doesn’t solve the problem it claims to solve. It builds a machine that can never be satisfied.
First, their claim
Let me give the other side its best case, because I think you persuade people by beating their strongest argument, not their weakest.
The MIT tool is legitimate. It was built in 2003 by Dr. Amy Glasmeier, an economic geographer at MIT, originally as an alternative to the federal poverty line, which everyone agreed was a blunt and dated instrument. What it does is genuinely useful: it adds up the real cost of a basic life in a given place — housing, food, childcare, healthcare, transportation, and taxes — and converts that into the hourly wage one full-time worker would need to cover it without leaning on public assistance.
And the gap it reveals is real. In large stretches of this country, the legal minimum wage does not come close to what it costs to keep a roof overhead. That is not a talking point. That is arithmetic, and conservatives do themselves no favors by pretending the cost-of-living squeeze is imaginary. It isn’t. People feel it because it’s true.
So if you stop the story there, the policy writes itself. The floor is too low. Raise the floor to match the cost. Done.
Except the story doesn’t stop there. That’s where it gets interesting.
One correction before we go further
A quick housekeeping note, because the morning-show version flattened it. You may have heard the study described as one figure that covers most states, with a slightly higher figure for a handful of others. That is not what the MIT data is. It is the opposite of that.
The calculator produces a separate figure for more than three thousand counties — because rent in rural Mississippi and rent in Honolulu have almost nothing to do with each other. A companion analysis this year pegged what a family of four needs at roughly twenty-five dollars an hour in Mississippi and nearly seventy in Hawaii. When you hear “the state living wage,” someone has usually averaged a whole state’s counties into a single number for convenience. Useful shorthand. But it is not a national wage waiting to be enacted, and that distinction matters for everything that follows.
Where does the number come from?
Here is the question the cheerful version of this story never asks. That living-wage figure — where does it come from? It is not revealed truth. It is constructed. It is built, line by line, out of local prices: rent, groceries, the cost of childcare, the premium on health insurance. The number is, at bottom, a measurement of what things cost where you live.
Hold onto that, because it’s the whole ballgame: the living wage is a measurement of prices. Now watch what happens when you take a measurement and turn it into a mandate.
The loop
Suppose you do it. You order every employer in the state to pay the calculated living wage. Labor is now more expensive. And businesses, as a rule, do not absorb higher costs out of civic affection — they pass them along. The diner’s breakfast costs more. The daycare raises its rates, and notice the daycare gets hit coming and going, because its single largest expense is the very labor you just made pricier. Meanwhile you’ve put more dollars into more pockets in the same town, chasing the same fixed supply of apartments, so rents drift upward too.
And now look at what you’ve done. Rent and childcare are two of the largest line items in the living-wage calculation to begin with. You have just driven up the precise costs the number is built from.
So next year MIT runs the numbers again. And the cost of living has gone up — partly because of what you did. The living wage recalculates, higher. Which means the wage you mandated is now, once again, below the living wage. So the pressure builds to mandate again. And around it goes. You have indexed the cure to the disease and then wondered why the patient never recovers.
The objection — and the honest answer
Now, I’ve learned to argue against myself before the other side does it for me. So let me put the strongest objection on the table, because if I don’t, a competent economist will.
They’ll say: you’re overstating the loop. Labor is only a fraction of what any good or service costs — often a quarter or less. Raise wages ten percent and prices do not jump ten percent, because wages aren’t the whole price. The circle doesn’t close. You don’t end up exactly back where you started.
And that objection is correct. It does not fully close. I’ll concede that cleanly, because overclaiming is how you lose the smart half of the room.
But here is the answer: it doesn’t have to close to trap you. It only has to move. This was never a perfect circle. It’s a ratchet. Each turn, you lift wages, prices follow part of the way, the target slides upward, and you’ve gained far less real ground than the headline suggests — all while congratulating yourself that the problem is handled. Partial pass-through doesn’t rescue the policy. It just makes the failure slower and harder to see.
The part nobody mentions: housing
And then there’s the cruelest piece, the one the morning segments skipped entirely. Housing is the single biggest driver of that whole number. Rent moves the living wage more than anything else on the list.
You cannot wage-mandate an apartment into existence. When you push more dollars into a town without adding one new unit of housing, you have not made housing affordable. You’ve simply called an auction. Same number of apartments, more money bidding for them, prices up. The family you set out to rescue is still outbid — they just have more zeros printed on their losing ticket. We told ourselves we were raising their standard of living, and instead we handed the gain straight to their landlord.
Treat the patient, not the thermometer
So what’s the honest verdict?
The MIT number is a thermometer, and a fairly good one. It is telling us something true and uncomfortable: in much of the country, what things cost has outrun what people earn. Don’t shoot the messenger; the reading is accurate.
But you do not cure a fever by holding a match under the thermometer. If the disease is the price of housing and the price of childcare, then the treatment is more housing and more childcare — supply — not a wage chase that bids up the very things we are already short of. Zoning reform, permitting reform, getting government’s boot off new construction, easing the regulatory load that makes childcare scarce and expensive: these are slower, less satisfying, and far harder to fit on a chyron than “mandate a living wage.” They also happen to be the things that actually move the number in the right direction.
Measure the fever. By all means. But let’s treat the patient — not the thermometer.
I received this email from one of my readers who happens to be a friend, so I knew if I didn’t honestly analyze it he would hound me until I did. Thanks. Now I had to spend part of last night and this morning re-analyzing what I wrote. :). But I do think it deserves an answer. Posting it here without attribution but with his words intact, because his pushback makes this piece sharper:
Quote from your sub-stack on this topic: “here is what it costs to actually live, here is the wage a family would need to cover it, and — the unspoken close — isn’t it a scandal that nobody is requiring employers to pay it?”
The logic flaw in the question “isn’t it a scandal that nobody is requiring employers to pay it?” is that the so called “living wage figure” is that it is the total HOUSEHOLD INCOME for a family of four.
So what if the prospective employee is a a single man or woman? Should ten employer be required to offer that single individual the same salary as the head of a 4 person household? And if not, since the prospective employer is not allowed to inquire about your marital status during an employment interview, how would they know what starting salary they would legally be required to offer you?
And if you did hire a single young man at a $22 per hour rate of pay and 6 months later he marries his pregnant girlfriend and she gives birth to twins, would the employer be obligated to immediately increase his rate of pay to $38 per hour while others in the store doing the exact same job are still making the original $22 per hour rate of pay?
And since that living wage figure is a HOUSEHOLD INCOME figure, how does it account for that fact that more than half of all middle class households have multiple adult wage earners in the home?
Here’s my answer.
First, the credit, because he earned it. He is right that the MIT figure is built from a household budget — the calculator totals a family’s basic needs, divides by the number of working adults, then divides by 2,080 hours. So the published number is contingent on an assumed family structure, and you genuinely can’t bolt a household-contingent figure onto an individual job posting. An employer can’t ask marital or family status, couldn’t lawfully price an offer to it if they could, and would hit the twins problem the moment anyone’s life changed. As a point about whose number it is, it’s airtight.
But here’s why I’m not going to let that become the whole conversation — and this is the part I want everyone reading to remember:
It doesn’t matter who’s right about the income figure. The mechanism is identical either way.
Whether the “right” number is the single adult’s wage or the family-of-four’s wage, whether you mandate the high figure or the low one — the loop runs the same. Raise the wage floor by law, and you’ve raised the employer’s labor cost. The employer raises prices to cover it. Those higher prices raise the cost of living for everyone in town — including the cost of the very things the “living wage” is calculated from: rent, groceries, childcare. So next year the living wage recalculates higher, and the floor you just set is underwater again. Mandate, prices rise, costs rise, mandate again. Round and round.
That’s my argument, and notice what it survives. It survives being wrong about the income figure. It survives my friend being smarter than me about household composition (he is after all an engineer, and I’m only a recovering lawyer — I know my limitations). Pick any number you like off that MIT chart and feed it into the mechanism: you get the same loop. This is simply the minimum-wage argument every economist already understands, wearing a new “living wage” costume. We just dressed up an old idea in nicer clothes and acted surprised to see it.
So the household-income point, fascinating as it is, is a debate about which number goes into the machine. My article is about the machine. And the machine doesn’t care.
Now — since I’d never deny an engineer his correction — two technical notes, because he’ll check:
One: there’s no single “the” living wage. MIT publishes twelve family types, from one childless adult to two adults with three kids. The television report I heard quotes the four-person version, which is why it sounds like “the” number. It’s twelve numbers, which only makes “just mandate it” more incoherent — mandate which?
Two — and this one I’ll hand him with both hands, because it tightens his own best point: the figure isn’t total household income. It’s already a per-worker number. MIT assumes the second adult earns the same wage and divides the budget by the number of earners. That’s exactly why the single-breadwinner numbers look so huge — one income carrying the whole load doesn’t get divided down. (Which means the twins example slightly overstates the jump. The logic is bulletproof; the arithmetic got away from him by a hair. Call it even — the engineer caught the better counterpoint, the lawyer caught the better math. I’ll take that trade and frame the receipt, especially when it comes to the math!)
And his closing question is the real prize, so let me answer it head-on: he notes the figure assumes a second earner, then asks how it squares with the fact that so many households have multiple earners. It squares badly, and that’s the point. Roughly half of all married couples are dual-earner — about two-thirds of those with kids (BLS, 2025, before he asks). So a mandate tied to the one-earner figure would overpay that dual-earner majority, while one tied to the two-earner figure would crush the sole breadwinner. There is no single number correct for both households doing the identical job. The same math that makes this a useful thermometer makes it impossible as a thermostat — it reads the temperature fine, but try to set the room with it and it breaks.
Keep the emails like this coming. They’re better than most of what I write. But I would never tell him that.



Who has looked at affordability from the supply side? Maybe compare to other countries, for example, village style versus suburbia and big city. Enough of a yard or communal plots where people can supplement their food. Also as Carol Roth writes we’re headed to owning nothing. Remote workers contribute less to the local economy. I think being able to own your own home is a path to wealth and to stabilizing the economy. Wouldn’t that be a way to fix your housing price long term. Living a reciprocal lifestyle where neighbors trade services like lawn care for childcare. Anything where you’re less of a cog in the machine.