7 Comments
User's avatar
Colette Bowdish's avatar

If we take your framing seriously, the lesson of the 1947 British note is not that Britain merely ran out of money. It is that Britain had accumulated global commitments that its economic base could no longer support. When the bill came due, it had to tell the United States that it could no longer carry responsibilities it once considered essential.

So, what should America give up to avoid ever having to write that note?

My answer would be:

America should give up the illusion that it can do everything, everywhere, forever.

Specifically:

Give up chronic deficit spending that is not building future strength. A nation can borrow heavily for wars, emergencies, infrastructure, or transformative investments. But if debt grows faster than national productive capacity, eventually choices become constrained. Britain's postwar problem was not simply debt. It was that its obligations exceeded its means. America must ensure its economy grows faster than its long-term commitments.

Give up unnecessary overseas commitments. A superpower's credibility comes from keeping promises. But promises should be selective. Every military guarantee, aid commitment, and security obligation carries a cost. If commitments expand indefinitely while resources do not, the gap eventually becomes unsustainable.

Give up short-term consumption in favor of long-term investment. Countries remain powerful because they produce, innovate, educate, and build. Economic strength is the foundation beneath military and diplomatic strength. When production weakens and consumption dominates, influence becomes harder to sustain. (BTW I think Trump realizes this more than any other recent president and I hope his promised investments from other countries is real.)

Give up political paralysis. Great powers do not usually decline because a single enemy defeats them. More often they decline because they become unable to make difficult decisions. If a country cannot reform spending, taxation, immigration, education, infrastructure, or defense when necessary, its options narrow over time.

Give up the belief that reserve-currency status is permanent. Britain once sat at the center of the global financial system. By 1947 it was still influential, but it no longer possessed the economic dominance required to support its previous role. America's advantages are enormous, but they are not laws of nature. Maintaining them requires constant renewal.

The deeper answer is this:

To remain the country that never has to write that note, America must be willing to sacrifice comfort before it is forced to sacrifice responsibility.

Britain did not choose the timing when it told the United States it could no longer support Greece and Turkey. Circumstances chose for it. The goal for America should be to make difficult adjustments voluntarily, while it is still strong, rather than have circumstances make them later.

In one sentence: America should give up excess commitments, excess debt, and short-term thinking, because great powers collapse into retrenchment when their promises grow faster than their capacity to fulfill them.

L C's avatar

And, one of those main "promises" that America not only has been shoveling out in recent years but is expected to is giving all this free housing, food, medical care, etc to immigrants.

Just take the cost of food. Look at your own household food costs. And, you may not even have the 3-4 children these immigrants have. Then multiply that by the millions who have been getting their food paid by the government. It must be staggering!

We need to get back to the Ellis Island way of allowing immigrants into this country. And, the current Washington administration is trying to do that to an extent. But, if it goes back to the Democrats it will never get under control I fear.

Chan Bailey's avatar

The US doesn't have to give up anything - we should want to be that country. Why? Because I/we don't want to trust some other country to protect us and pull our butts out of the fire, and then control us. The cost of being that country is far less than the cost of giving up our freedom. We have work to do, no doubt about it - our debt must be gotten under control and our military must be built up if we want to maintain any semblance of world peace. Give someone else a turn? Absolutely not. There is no one out there I am willing to trust with our economy and, more importantly, our freedom. It's hard enough to trust our own government, much less one where I don't have a vote.

L C's avatar

Thank you for this two-part take. I didn't have two cups of coffee but a good Ole low budget British food dish called Bubble and Squeak. As I mentioned in a reply to someone else food costs need to come down in this country. And, I don't mean just store prices though that certainly would help.

And, I don't mean your diet coke habit. Though drinks are the least expensive item at McDonald's these days. Though I allow myself to have a cheeseburger every now and then. Even a double cheeseburger if I feel I'm rolling in money.

Tim Mabbott's avatar

What should America give up? Let’s start with greed. 40 trillion in National Debt must be faced. As you point out the interest alone is sapping our ability to fund government expense. How did we get here? Compare the ratio of salaries between top executives and their base employees in the 50’s when Great Britian ceded the world to us and now. Look at the income tax rates paid by all economic levels in the 50’s and now. What’s the difference? According to the Federal Reserve the top 1% of Americans own 31.6 % of United States’ wealth, while the bottom 50% own 2.5% income. How did we get here? Did some of us get a little greedy? Contrary to the values of “the greatest generation” who fought World War 2, did some of us did some of us decide to put our individual entitlement above the welfare of our nation? Did we ignore the call President Kennedy offered? "Ask not what your country can do for you—ask what you can do for your country" Did both Democrats and Republicans seek to buy our votes with tax cuts at the expense of our national welfare? A spiritual mentor once asked me when I would feel I had enough. Enough income, enough house, enough car, enough stuff. “Until you know what enough is,” Ian said, “you will always feel poor.” Let’s give up greed! (I know, easy to say when I’m a member of the middle, middle class, but mostly because my schoolteacher parents left an estate)

Second, we should give up the hubris that America can remain great without anyone else. Think about population. My favorite analogy is high school football: a school with 2,400 students does not compete against one with 600 students because the larger school has four times the pool of potential talent, size, strength, and depth. Yet every day, the United States, with a population of about 343 million, competes with China at 1.41 billion and India at 1.47 billion. We have succeeded because we had better coaches (our universities and research centers) --stronger facilities (our infrastructure)—and the ability to recruit beyond our own district (immigration). Unfortunately, we are increasingly losing the manufacturing race, in part because China and India each have workforces about four times the size of ours. My father, who flew “the Humps” during World War II, marveled at how quickly 10,000 Chinese workers with hammers could build a hard gravel runway for his supply plane to land. The bottom line is that we need everyone willing to build a life here. We need immigrants and allies, just as Great Britain did during World War II. We must stop thinking of millions of hard-working immigrants as “them” and find a way for all to be part of “us.” There are more things we need to give up, but let’s start with greed and hubris.

Michael P.  Connelly's avatar

Michael, I know sports is not your “thing.”

But analyze two historic, systemic shifts in sports:

Curt Flood, Cardinals, ‘68, baseball free agency.

NIL in college football today …

NIL shares the millions that only the athletes generate.

Nick Saban who earned 13 million a year as a head coach hates the fact players get paid. I never saw him make a tackle. I never saw him throw a touchdown. He just intimidated and acted crusty and has no personality and is just a selfish mongrel.

NIL is A true “free market.”

Sports is an industry. Content is king. Coaches are barnacles.

College players are worth way more than the “scholarship.“

They obliterate their bodies over four or five years in their prime for the hope of getting a taste of pro money, while getting bullied by their power-mongering head coaches.

They get nothing but a scholarship.

Now some players are making millions.

It’s the millions that would’ve just gone to the institutions.

The bigger question really is this: why do colleges and universities have sports franchises? Really think about that!

And why is it so revolting that the players that destroy their bodies for the sake of the entertainment of others are being vilified for actually making ordinary income.

I broke a story that George Steinbrenner got banished for life from the IOC and the USOC for paying all of the athletes living in Colorado Springs $400 a week to live and attend the “Olympic Village.”

Of course, the IOC said that the amateurs needed to go out and get jobs.

Tell that to the Russians and Germans.

Do you think the USOC really thought out how many jobs would be available in puny Colorado Springs at the time?

Now circle back to free-agent Curt Flood.

Major league baseball shares its revenue 50-50 with the players.

No Curt Flood, billionaires just making more billions.

Ask Dragon how Lance is doing!