If you’ve spent any time in the company of serious fiscal conservatives — the kind who actually think about tax policy rather than just complaining about their bill — you’ve heard the argument for a consumption-based tax system. It goes something like this: taxing labor is a penalty on productivity. You work harder, you earn more, the government takes a larger cut. That’s not just economically inefficient; it’s morally backwards. Tax what people spend, not what they earn, and you align the government’s incentives with economic growth rather than against it.
It’s a coherent argument. I’ve made it myself. The Fair Tax, the flat tax, consumption-based reform — the details differ but the principle is the same: honest, transparent, universal taxation on what you consume rather than what you produce.
Here’s what Colorado’s legislature just did to that argument: they broke it. Not by defeating it in debate. By implementing a grotesque parody of it.
What a Fair Consumption Tax Actually Looks Like
Before we get to the parody, let’s be precise about the original.
A genuine consumption tax — whether a national sales tax, a VAT, or a flat-rate expenditure tax — has three defining characteristics. It is transparent: you see exactly what you’re paying and why. It is universal: everyone who participates in the economy pays it, at the same rate, on the same basis. And it is democratic: the rate is set through a visible political process that voters can reward or punish at the ballot box.
Those three characteristics are not incidental features. They are the entire moral case for consumption taxation. The argument isn’t simply that consumption taxes are economically efficient — though they are. It’s that they’re honest. The government tells you the price of citizenship, you pay it, and everyone can see the transaction.
That’s the theory. Now meet the practice.
The Parody Version
As I documented Tuesday, Colorado’s fee enterprise system has become the dominant engine of state revenue growth. Fee collections per resident have grown from $225 in 2000 to $4,322 in 2024 — nearly twenty times over, while General Fund tax revenue per resident grew from $1,209 to $2,614. The fees now dwarf the taxes.
And what are those fees, structurally? They are consumption-based charges. You register your car — fee. You use a toll road — fee. You rent a vehicle — fee. Your utility company passes through an enterprise surcharge — fee. You are being taxed, functionally, on transactions. On consumption.
So in theory, fiscal conservatives should be fine with this, right? Consumption-based revenue, just like we asked for.
Except that it violates every single one of the three defining characteristics of an honest consumption tax.
It is not transparent. The charges are disaggregated across dozens of enterprise funds, buried in utility statements, folded into registration renewals, embedded in rental agreements. There is no single line that says: Colorado consumed $4,322 of your income this year in fees. The Common Sense Institute had to do forensic accounting across the entire state budget to produce that number. You shouldn’t need a think tank to know your tax burden.
It is not universal. Different fees hit different people depending on what they drive, where they live, what utilities they use, and what services they access. The burden falls asymmetrically — and notably, it falls regressively. A $15 vehicle registration fee increase represents a far higher percentage of a working-class family’s income than it does for a household earning six figures. A genuine consumption tax, properly structured, can be made progressive through rebates or exemptions. Colorado’s fee structure has no such architecture. It just hits whoever happens to be in the path of each individual enterprise.
And it is emphatically not democratic. As I laid out Tuesday, Colorado voters said no to more taxation four separate times. The fee increases came anyway, through a mechanism specifically designed to circumvent that democratic verdict. A genuine consumption tax gets enacted by a legislature accountable to voters, debated openly, and subject to repeal. Colorado’s fee regime was engineered precisely to avoid that process.
So what Colorado has given fiscal conservatives is consumption-based taxation stripped of every virtue that makes consumption taxation worth defending. The economic distortion of taxing transactions? Present. The transparency, universality, and democratic accountability that justify it? Absent. It is the worst of both worlds: you still pay income tax, and you now pay what amounts to a hidden, regressive, unvoted consumption tax on top of it.
The Cruelest Irony
Here is where it gets genuinely infuriating, at least for those of us who have spent years arguing that consumption taxes are more honest than income taxes.
Since 2018, Colorado voters approved three income tax cuts — a combined reduction of 0.38 percentage points. We celebrated. The rate came down. Labor was being penalized slightly less.
Meanwhile, the Common Sense Institute’s data shows that fee-based revenue to non-higher-education enterprises increased over the same period by the equivalent of a 1.5 percentage-point income tax increase. We won the visible fight and lost the invisible one by a ratio of roughly four to one.
The legislature, in effect, let us have our income tax cuts — knowing full well that they were simultaneously imposing a larger consumption-based extraction through fees that we’d never see coming, never aggregate, and never connect to the income tax debate we thought we were winning.
That is not fiscal policy. That is a three-card monte game played with your paycheck.
The Solution Nobody Wants to Say Out Loud
The fix isn’t complicated to describe, even if it’s politically nuclear to implement.
Every Colorado household should receive an annual statement — one document, one number — showing the total fees paid to state enterprise funds during the prior year. Not buried in individual bills. Not distributed across twelve different transactions. One invoice. Colorado State Fee Collections: Your Household, FY2024: $4,322.
That single act of transparency would do more for fiscal accountability than any constitutional amendment, any supermajority requirement, any Prop 117. Because the anesthesia only works in the dark. Turn the lights on and the patient wakes up.
Republicans, if they’re paying attention — and that’s admittedly an open question — have a ready-made campaign platform sitting in the Common Sense Institute’s data. Not a tax increase argument. Not an abstract TABOR debate. A receipt. Here’s what they took. Here’s what they called it. Here’s what they said it was for. Now vote accordingly.
Whether they’re smart enough to use it is, as I noted Tuesday, an open question.
But the argument is there. The data is there. The case is airtight.
The only thing missing is the political will to hand every Colorado voter the bill they’ve already been paying — and haven’t been allowed to see.
The Common Sense Institute’s “Snapshot of Fees in Colorado: 2025 Update” is available at commonsenseinstituteus.org. Read Tuesday’s piece, “The Anesthesia Tax,” for the full breakdown of the fee enterprise data.


If we only had an organized and capable Republican Party in Colorado with effective leadership…..if only…..