THE DOCUMENT
Every so often, a political movement does you the enormous favor of writing down exactly what it wants. No leaked memo. No hidden-camera sting. No opposition researcher connecting dots on a corkboard. Just a document — drafted, debated, amended, and adopted by the organization’s own governing body, published under its own name. And when that happens, you have two choices. You can take them at their word, or you can let some cable news contributor pat you on the head and tell you it’s really all just about affordable child care.
Last month, the Democratic Socialists of America’s National Political Committee — think of it as their board of directors, the seventeen people who run the organization between conventions — met in person and adopted a rebooted national platform. It’s called “Workers Deserve More!” and they are rolling it out publicly right now, this week. So let me tell you what’s actually in it, from the document and the reporting on the meeting where it passed, not from a tweet.
Eliminate the United States Senate. Replace the President — the one you elect — with an executive chosen by Congress and answerable to Congress. Replace the Supreme Court with a judiciary that is likewise, in the platform’s own words, “subordinate to Congress.” Grant amnesty to every person in the country illegally, on top of their existing calls to end all deportations, open migration entirely, and extend voting rights to noncitizens. Defund the Department of War. Close America’s overseas military bases. End all economic sanctions — including, one assumes, the ones currently squeezing the regime in Tehran. Abolish what the platform calls the carceral forces of the capitalist state, which is graduate-seminar language for police and prisons. And because the current Constitution won’t permit most of this — more on that in a minute — the platform says the quiet part in bold print: the goal is to draft a new constitution and build a new society from the ground up.
Now, I know what some of you are thinking. It’s a wish list from an activist group. Why give it a full segment, let alone three? Here’s why. The DSA has a mayor sitting in Gracie Mansion running the largest city in America. In just the last several months, DSA-endorsed challengers knocked off four sitting Democratic members of Congress — in New York, in Michigan, and yes, right here in Colorado. More than two hundred fifty DSA members now hold elected office across forty states, the overwhelming majority elected in just the past few years. This is not the Trotskyite reading circle down the hall from your college student union anymore. It is a movement with real electoral machinery, and platforms are what movements publish right before they start governing. Every platform is just a wish list — right up until the day it isn’t.
THEIR BEST CASE
So let’s do this the right way. Before I take this apart, let me make their argument better than most of them make it — because you are going to hear it at a barbecue this summer, and you deserve the honest version, not a strawman.
The argument goes like this. The Senate is anti-democratic: Wyoming’s roughly six hundred thousand people get the same two senators as California’s thirty-nine million. The Electoral College has twice this century handed the presidency to the candidate who lost the popular vote. The Supreme Court — nine unelected lawyers with lifetime tenure — struck down a student loan forgiveness program that a duly elected president ran on. So if you actually believe in democracy, they say — one person, one vote, majority rules — then the Senate, the independent presidency, and the independent judiciary are all just barriers standing between the people and what the people voted for. Sweep them away, put everything under one elected legislature, and you finally get what they call real democracy. One DSA leader defending the platform even reached back to Woodrow Wilson, who spent his academic career complaining that the separation of powers made American government slow and inefficient.
That is the case. It is internally coherent. People you know believe some version of it. And it is precisely, exactly, deliberately wrong — and I mean deliberately, because the men who designed our system heard this exact argument, considered it carefully, and rejected it on the evidence.
WHAT THE FOUNDERS KNEW
Here’s what the real-democracy crowd either doesn’t know or hopes you don’t. The Founders were intimately familiar with legislative supremacy. They didn’t fail to think of it — they lived under it. Parliament was, and formally still is, supreme in Britain. There is no British Senate that can be abolished, no entrenched constitution a British court can enforce against Parliament. The entire American founding — 1776 followed by 1787 — is the story of people discovering that a legislature can tyrannize you every bit as thoroughly as a king, and then building a system to prevent both.
Madison put it flatly in Federalist 47: concentrating legislative, executive, and judicial power in the same hands is the very definition of tyranny. Notice what he did not say. He did not say in a king’s hands. He said the same hands. Any hands. Including — especially — the hands of a popularly elected legislature, because an elected body claiming to speak for the people is the hardest kind of power to resist.
And this wasn’t theory. Between independence and the Constitution, the states ran the experiment for us. Several adopted governments with dominant legislatures, weak governors, and weak courts. Pennsylvania went furthest — its 1776 constitution created a single all-powerful legislative chamber with no real executive and no independent judiciary. It is the closest thing to the DSA’s model ever tried on American soil, it produced factional chaos and legislative abuse almost immediately, and Pennsylvanians scrapped it within fourteen years. The Constitution of 1787 — two chambers, a separately elected president with a veto, life-tenured judges — was not an accident of eighteenth-century fashion. It was the correction. The friction, the gridlock, the endless checking of one branch by another that so exasperates the DSA? That’s not a bug they discovered. That’s the feature Madison advertised. Ambition made to counteract ambition — Federalist 51. The system is frustrating on purpose, because a government that can do anything quickly can do anything to you quickly.
THE SENATE AND THE STATES
Now to the Senate specifically, because abolishing it isn’t a tweak to the org chart. It dissolves the deal that created the country. The states are not administrative districts of the federal government. They are the parties to the compact — sovereign entities that gave up limited, enumerated powers in exchange for, among other things, an equal voice in one chamber. That was the Connecticut Compromise, and without it there is no Constitution, no ratification, no union. The House represents people; the Senate represents the states as states. Remove the Senate and federalism doesn’t get weaker — it ceases to exist as a structural fact.
The Framers took this so seriously that they made equal representation in the Senate the one provision in the entire document that the amendment process itself cannot touch. Read the last clause of Article V: no state, without its consent, shall be deprived of its equal suffrage in the Senate. You can amend the presidency. You can amend the courts. You cannot amend away a state’s Senate seats without that state agreeing to it. The DSA knows this — which is exactly why the platform doesn’t call for an amendment. It calls for a new constitution. Understand what that means: they are not proposing to reform the American system. They are proposing to replace it. And they said so in writing.
Let me bring this home. Colorado is about six million people — under two percent of the country. In the DSA’s vision of a single national legislature elected by proportional representation, Colorado as Colorado ceases to exist politically. The Colorado River compacts. Public lands. Oil and gas on the Western Slope. Water rights, grazing rights, how we run our own fiscal house under TABOR — every one of those becomes a line item decided by whoever can assemble fifty percent plus one nationally, which in practice means the population corridors of a handful of coastal metros. The Senate is the institution that forces the coasts to negotiate with the interior. It is why a Colorado, a Montana, a Kansas has a seat at the table instead of a spot on the menu. Remove it, and flyover country stops being a punchline and becomes a governing philosophy.
RIGHTS OR PERMISSIONS
Now the courts — and this is the part I want you to be able to explain to your brother-in-law, because it’s the most dangerous piece and the least understood. Think about what the Bill of Rights actually is. It is a list of things majorities are not allowed to do to you. Congress shall make no law — that’s the First Amendment, and notice who it’s addressed to. Not the king. Not the bureaucracy. Congress. The Bill of Rights is, top to bottom, a set of restraints on the very legislature the DSA wants to make supreme.
And the only reason those restraints bind anyone is that an independent court can strike down the law that violates them. That’s been the deal since Marbury versus Madison in 1803, when Chief Justice Marshall established that it is the courts — not Congress grading its own homework — that say what the law is. Make the judiciary subordinate to Congress, and every right you have converts on the spot from a guarantee into a permission slip. Speech, religion, press, the Second Amendment, due process, private property — all of it revocable by simple majority on any given Tuesday, with no institution left standing that can say no. A court that answers to the legislature cannot enforce limits on the legislature. That’s not a flaw in their design. It is the design.
And here’s the tell that this was never really about democracy. The Supreme Court frustrates everybody. Yes, it blocked the last administration’s student loan forgiveness. It has also ruled against this administration — on the IEEPA tariffs, just weeks ago, a decision we spent two hours on right here. Same nine justices, same term, ruling against presidents of both parties. That is not a malfunction. An independent court is nobody’s servant, which is precisely why people who want unchecked power — of any flavor, left or right — always come for the courts first. One DSA committee member, arguing for this platform, complained that the whole point of the Senate, the presidency, and the Court is to give the ruling class levers to pull to stop popular legislation. Swap out ruling class for minorities of every kind — religious minorities, political minorities, property owners, gun owners, you — and he has accidentally written the best defense of the Constitution you’ll hear all year. Those levers are what stop fifty-one percent of the country from doing whatever it likes to the other forty-nine.
ONE POINT OF CAPTURE
At this point somebody always says: parliamentary systems exist. Britain, Canada, most of Europe — the legislature chooses the executive and the sky hasn’t fallen. True. But look at what those systems still have. Second chambers. Constitutional courts, or entrenched charters of rights that judges enforce. Federalism. Centuries of norms and, in most cases, coalition governments that force compromise. The DSA’s model has none of it. One chamber. No Senate. No independently elected executive. No independent judiciary. Courts and executive both subordinate to the same body, with police and national defense restructured underneath it.
History has seen that architecture before, and not in Ottawa. It’s the National Convention of revolutionary France. It’s the Supreme Soviet. On paper, total legislative democracy — everything answers to the people’s assembly. In practice, whoever controls the majority of that single assembly controls the legislature, the executive, the courts, and the enforcement apparatus, all at once, forever, with no institution left to appeal to. Concentration of power does not stop being concentration of power because the concentrating body won an election. Tyranny with better turnout is still tyranny.
THE ECONOMICS
And what would this consolidated government do with all that power? We don’t have to guess — the platform tells us. Public ownership of the largest corporations and essential industries. Universal rent control. A mandated thirty-two-hour work week at full forty-hour pay. Cancel all student debt, publicly finance every campaign, abolish the Electoral College — and, my personal favorite pairing, end all economic sanctions while defunding the military, so we’d be disarming ourselves and bankrolling our adversaries in the same fiscal year.
Take nationalization first. Prices are information. Profit and loss is the feedback loop that tells an economy what’s working, what’s wasteful, and where to send the next dollar of investment. When the state owns the enterprise, the feedback loop is political, not economic — the firm answers to the legislature’s priorities, not the customer’s. Britain’s nationalized industries before Thatcher, Venezuela’s oil company after Chávez — the record isn’t mixed. It’s monotonous. Output falls, quality falls, and the losses get quietly socialized onto taxpayers who were promised abundance.
Rent control is one of the rare subjects where economists left, right, and center actually agree. Assar Lindbeck — a Swedish social democrat, mind you, not a Chicago free-marketeer — famously observed that short of bombing, rent control is about the most reliable method ever devised for destroying a city. Cap the price and supply dries up, existing stock decays because upkeep no longer pays, and the shortage gets rationed by connections and luck instead of price. Ask anyone who’s tried to find an apartment in a rent-controlled market.
The thirty-two-hour mandate is a twenty percent increase in unit labor costs imposed by statute. Some of that comes out of hiring, some out of automation, some out of prices — none of it comes out of thin air. But here’s the deepest problem, and it ties the whole platform together: who invests capital in a company that Congress can vote to seize — when the court that would hear your takings claim answers to the same Congress doing the seizing? Property rights are not a luxury feature bolted onto free markets. They are the market. And in the DSA’s architecture, the referee who protects your property works for the player who wants it.
THE WORLD AS IT IS
A word on the world outside our borders, because the timing here is almost too on the nose. We have spent the first half of this year watching what happens when deterrence gets tested — a shooting conflict with Iran, the Strait of Hormuz in play, ceasefire diplomacy that only became possible because American power made the alternative worse. Into that world, the DSA proposes to defund the Pentagon, shutter our overseas bases, and drop every sanction on every adversary. That is not a foreign policy. It is a unilateral surrender of every instrument of national leverage short of hoping.
And pair the immigration plank with the voting plank, because structurally they’re one idea. Amnesty for everyone here illegally, an end to all deportations, open migration — and voting rights for noncitizens. Set aside the policy debate for a moment and see the architecture: if noncitizens vote and borders don’t bind, citizenship means nothing. And citizenship is the thing that makes consent of the governed a coherent concept in the first place. A government of, by, and for everyone in general is a government accountable to no one in particular.
THE VERDICT
So here’s where I land — and I want to give the DSA credit for one genuine virtue: honesty. They are not hiding the ball. The document says new constitution. It says build a new society from the ground up. When a movement with a mayor running America’s largest city, a growing bench in Congress, and two hundred fifty officeholders in forty states formally adopts a plan to abolish the Senate, subordinate the courts and the presidency to a single legislature, socialize major industries, and dissolve the meaning of citizenship — believe them. Do not let anyone launder it into free child care.
The Constitution is not an obstacle course somebody built to annoy progressives. It is the accumulated scar tissue of men who had studied majorities, monarchs, and mobs alike, and who understood that the question is never whether power will be abused. The only question is whether anything is left standing in the way when somebody tries. The two chambers. The veto. The independent courts. The states themselves. Every one of those is a wall — and the DSA has now published, under its own name, the demolition order for all of them at once, and called it democracy.
Benjamin Franklin, walking out of the Philadelphia convention in September of 1787, was asked what kind of government the delegates had produced. A republic, he answered — if you can keep it. Two hundred and thirty-nine years later, an organization with real and growing electoral power has formally resolved not to keep it. The very least we can do is read the paperwork. I just did it for you. Now go make sure your neighbors read it too.



DSA is code for Communist! They need to be defeated at every election! They must not be allowed to fester in our country! God help us!
We have allowed the public school system to be hijacked by educated idiots - (no grades- no cursive - back to marking an X on documents with witnesses or printed signatures - bias history - math and science teaching anything but - look at the latest national averages - 10th reading and 27th math (ORCD program from PISA). Parents need to get involved with their child’s education) Sadly many parents actually are not knowledgeable- or worse - don’t care. Therefore - today has become fertile ground for DSA. To stop the spread of disinformation must start young - at 18 years old it to late for most.