Over the last two days I’ve laid out two stories from District One — the four-county Oklahoma panhandle. In Part 1, a trucker named Tammy Votta exposed a drug task force that pulled $2.1 million out of passing truckers, $360 at a time, with nothing ever filed in court. In Part 2, one of the tips that exposé shook loose led to a fatal crash: a task force officer doing 85, a double fatality, a report stamped “incomplete,” and an 8-year-old girl left in the grass for six hours. Two scandals, same task force, same DA. Today: are they connected — and what does it all mean?
Let me start by talking you out of the easy answer, because the lazy version of this argument is also the wrong one.
I am not telling you the crash was buried in order to protect the ticketing revenue. I’m not telling you Halliburton was running a stop the night he killed two people, or that the two scandals share a paper trail, a memo, a phone call, a plan. There is no evidence for any of that. And if I stood up and claimed it, the first competent defense lawyer to read this — and I happen to know a good one in Oklahoma — would use that one overreach to discredit everything else I’ve shown you, including the parts that are bulletproof. A prosecutor who charges more than he can prove loses the whole case. So I won’t.
The connection is real. But it’s a connection of character, not of conspiracy. And here’s the uncomfortable part: that’s worse. You can fire a conspirator. You can indict a plan. You cannot so easily fix a culture — and a culture is exactly what these two stories, side by side, reveal.
Look at what they actually share.
Same institution, same closed loop
The District One Drug Task Force is the throughline. The five agents writing pay-to-disappear tickets are the same unit as the agent driving the Tahoe. The district attorney who “controls” that task force and banked the $2.1 million is the same district attorney who personally handled the public messaging on a fatal crash involving one of his own officers — producing the video, narrating the speeds, explaining away the airbags.
And watch how the dynasty runs. DA George “Buddy” Leach III inherited the ticketing program from the prior DA, James “Mike” Boring — the man Leach had practiced law with for seventeen years, at a firm called Boring and Leach.When the prosecutor who would theoretically charge wrongdoing is fused — institutionally and personally — to the agency that commits it, you don’t have a check. You have a hall of mirrors. Remember from Part 1: when the FBI looked into Votta’s complaint, it ended up phoning the very DA at the center of the thing. There was no outside. Every road led back to the same office.
Same instinct: keep it out of court
This is the deepest tell, and it’s the one a trial lawyer can’t walk past.
The entire genius of the ticketing scheme was that nothing was ever filed. The agent in charge said so out loud, and built his whole legal defense on it: until it hits the court, it’s the DA’s discretion. No docket. No judge. No record.
Now look at the crash. Scene cleared in thirty-eight minutes. Both cars towed before the fatality investigator arrived. No photographs. No interview of the lone survivor. A report stamped “incomplete.” Records surrendered only under the pressure of a lawsuit.
Two completely different events — and the same reflex underneath both: avoid the one forum where an independent party gets to ask hard questions and create a permanent record. The courthouse. The single thing No Man’s Land, historically, never had. Both the money operation and the crash investigation were engineered, consciously or not, to never produce the document that would let an outsider reconstruct what happened. That’s not two coincidences. That’s one habit, expressed twice.
Same attitude: “we can probably get by with this”
The one-day shutdown of the ticketing program tells you these were people who knew, on some level, that daylight was fatal to what they were doing. That’s not the confidence of the righteous — it’s the confidence of people who’d simply never been made to answer for anything.
And the sloppiness of the crash investigation is precisely what that same confidence looks like when nobody’s filming. You don’t photograph a scene you’ve never been forced to account for. You don’t test the officer when no one has ever required it. You don’t interview the grandmother when her family has never once made the system pay a price for ignoring them. The shoddiness isn’t only incompetence. It’s competence aimed at a different target — closure, not truth. They could get by with the tickets for six years and $2.1 million. Why on earth would they expect to be questioned about a car wreck?
Same victims
And here’s the part that should trouble a free-market conservative most of all, because it is the predictable output of the broken machine, not a random cruelty.
When you strip the external check off an institution, the risk it generates doesn’t vanish. It gets transferred — and it rolls downhill, every time, to whoever has the least power to push back. The ticketing scheme picked off out-of-state truckers who’d rather pay $360 than litigate in a county they’d never see again. The crash investigation steamrolled a Guatemalan immigrant family — a dead patriarch who couldn’t testify, a surviving grandmother nobody bothered to interview, a community that assumed, correctly, that the system wasn’t built to hear them.
Same design flaw. Same selection of the same kind of victim. That isn’t coincidence. That’s physics. Unaccountable power doesn’t pick its targets at random; it finds the people who can’t fight back and bills them for the privilege.
Why this should bother you even if you back the badge
I want to close where I suspect a good chunk of you instinctively start: on the side of law enforcement. Good. So am I. Which is exactly why this matters.
The legitimacy of a prosecutor’s office and a police force is not a renewable resource you can spend down forever. It rests on a single proposition: that the law applies the same to the people enforcing it as to the people subject to it. The moment a community watches a task force turn traffic stops into a private revenue stream with no court involved — and then watches that same office handle the death of a child at the hands of one of its own with no photographs, no test, no interview, and a story that changes every time the documents contradict it — the proposition collapses. Not just for the guilty. For everyone. The law-abiding rancher. The churchgoing trucker with a clean 21-year record. The immigrant who came here precisely because he believed the system was different from the one he left behind.
This is the conservative case against unchecked government power, and it has nothing to do with being soft on crime — it’s the opposite. It’s the oldest insight we have, and Madison wrote it down for us: if men were angels, no government would be necessary, and because they are not, you build the checks before you need them. Take away the courthouse, the second set of eyes, the credible fear of being told no — and human nature does the rest, every time, regardless of how decent the people were when they started. This is not a story about uniquely wicked men in the panhandle. It’s a story about what any institution becomes when you remove the friction.
No Man’s Land got its courthouse on the map in 1890. The tragedy of District One — and the friend of mine who knows these stories put his finger on exactly this — is that in every way that actually counts, it’s still No Man’s Land. The building is there. The judge is there. But the check that building was supposed to house never fully moved in. And until it does, the bill for that vacancy will keep coming due — paid, as it always is, by the people least able to afford it.
An 8-year-old girl named Petronila paid part of that bill on an embankment of scrub grass, forty feet from her grandfather’s car, while the people whose job was to look for her went home.
We can at least refuse to let it stay quiet. That’s the one thing No Man’s Land was never able to survive.
This concludes the three-part series. Part 1: The Toll Booth on U.S. 54 · Part 2: The Girl in the Grass


Thank you for this story and especially this part to make us think.
I believe the "liberal" nature of law enforcement via the DA's drug task force begins with the state's search and seizure laws. It only takes a suspicion to be accused, seized and a whole heap of trouble getting it all back if charges aren't pursued (or the defendant "wins" in court). I believe this led to a cowboy culture within this and similar task forces in the state leading up to the events you described. Look up the case of Bill Cicco in 2013.
For the record, my grandfather, Frank Ogden, a longstanding former District Judge for this area, was opposed to seizure on suspicion (of drug trafficking). He knew the risk from the beginning.
Great series, Michael - thank you for researching this and shedding daylight!