Ballot Issue 7A was right there on my ballot. Front Range Passenger Rail District. A new sales tax to pay for a passenger train. BallotTrax told me my ballot was mailed. Then it arrived. It sat on my desk for a couple of days while I contemplated what to do with the line containing the vote on the Cuckoo for Coco (my moniker not theirs) train. No, not how to vote. That was always going to be no. But whether to vote, considering the utter screwup on the ballot containing that issue when I do not live in the district.
I read it twice.
I don’t live in the Front Range Passenger Rail District. In Douglas County, the legislature left exactly two places inside the district this year: Sterling Ranch, and the sliver of Littleton that crosses the county line. I live in neither. I knew that before I picked up the pen. I knew the question had no business being on my ballot.
I filled in the oval next to NO anyway.
On purpose.
I wanted to see what would happen to it. I’m a retired lawyer. I spent years inside government. When an election office tells me not to worry, my reflex is to ask for the paperwork.
Here’s what I found. I still can’t tell you what happens to my ballot. Neither can anyone else I’ve been able to find.
* * *
Start with what we know for certain.
According to 9News, Douglas County mailed 7A to all 289,000 of its voters. The Colorado Sun reported Monday that about 282,800 of them got it by mistake. That’s about 98% of the ballots in this county carrying a tax question for a district those voters don’t live in.
Douglas County had company. Adams, Arapahoe and Weld counties made the same mistake. By the Sun’s latest count, about 835,000 Coloradans got a ballot asking them to decide a tax they have no legal right to decide. Former Secretary of State Wayne Williams told The Denver Post he isn’t aware of anything remotely close to this magnitude. The Sun wrote that it’s hard to remember a bigger election-season screwup.
Here’s the part that stings. The tax would apply to purchases made inside the district. Every time I buy something in Denver or Littleton, I’d pay it. I just don’t get a say.
The mess traces back to a law the legislature passed this spring, Senate Bill 26-172. The old district reached into 13 counties. I read the new law. It names 31 cities and towns, Littleton among them, plus Sterling Ranch’s seven metropolitan districts in unincorporated Douglas County. Somebody needed to tell the county clerks who prints which question on which ballot.
Nobody did.
Sal Pace, the rail district’s general manager, apologized. He said the district should have walked every county clerk through the change. He also told FOX31 the district had no legal obligation to do it.
The Secretary of State’s office told FOX31 it certified the ballot content, and that notifying counties about special-district boundaries isn’t its responsibility.
Douglas County Clerk and Recorder Sheri Davis said the only boundary map the district ever gave her office showed all of Douglas County inside the district. That’s what her office printed.
She has a point. Arapahoe County’s elections director, Bill Mast, told the Sun his office emailed the district and never got an answer. The map on the district’s own website, he said, still showed the old boundaries.
That answer has a problem, and the problem lives one county south.
El Paso County’s clerk, Steve Schleiker, told The Denver Post he emailed the rail district in July asking for the new boundaries. He never heard back. His office drew the 7A boundaries from the bill itself. The Post reviewed his email.
The law was public. The list of cities sits on page three.
The old district touched 13 counties. The state named four that got this wrong. The other nine aren’t on the list.
The rail district apologized but says it wasn’t required to tell anyone. The state points at the district. Douglas County points at the map it was handed. Mr. Williams, the former secretary of state, says the state carries some of the blame too.
El Paso’s clerk read the law and did the job.
Here’s a detail that surfaced Monday. Once the error came to light, somebody had to decide whether 7A stayed on the ballot at all. According to Mr. Mast, that call belonged to the rail district. The district didn’t withdraw it.
The district that caused the mess decided to keep the vote going.
* * *
The fix, we’re told, is handled. As of this writing, counties are allowed to start processing ballots. The state set that date: Monday, October 19.
On Wednesday, October 7, the state’s elections director, Judd Choate, sent the four counties written instructions. Program the voting machines to count 7A only for eligible voters. Test the setup. For most ballots, the state says, the machines can sort eligible from ineligible by ballot style. Weld County’s clerk, Carly Koppes, told CBS Colorado the machines read the style from barcodes and timing marks printed on each ballot.
In Douglas County, Sterling Ranch is the exception the state named. There, according to the state’s guidance, neighbors who received the identical ballot aren’t all eligible. Those envelopes get pulled for hand review. Eligible voters get counted normally. For each ineligible voter, election workers verify the signature, separate the ballot from the envelope, and then fill out a brand-new ballot on that voter’s behalf. The new one leaves out 7A.
Read that again.
To fix one tax question, election workers will re-create entire ballots. The governor’s race. The US Senate race. The county commissioner. The clerk’s own race. Every choice on those ballots gets copied by human beings onto a fresh ballot.
The clerk’s race is Mrs. Davis’s race. She’s on this November’s ballot, running for re-election.
How many ballots will be copied? Nobody has said.
The number exists. Colorado’s election rules already require a written log of every duplicated ballot, with the date, the reason, and the names of the two election judges who made the copy.
In a Denver7 story posted Sunday, Mrs. Davis explained her office’s plan. She said her staff identifies voters by their voter ID as envelopes run through the sorter, and sets them aside in their own batches. Her office counts the 7A batches, then, in her words, will “turn off 7A for the rest of the batches.” She told voters to fill out the whole ballot, 7A included, and promised only eligible votes will count. Her office’s website is gentler. Vote on 7A or leave it blank, it says, and the rest of your ballot won’t be affected.
A county election worker who watched a demonstration told Denver7 she was reassured. She described a test run on generated ballots, with no real votes on them, and a filter that pulled out the ineligible ones. She compared it to the routine process when a candidate drops out after ballots are mailed.
I don’t doubt the people doing this work. They’re careful, and they care.
The comparison doesn’t fit. When a candidate drops out, every voter is still eligible for the race. One name goes to zero. Here, the question is which voters count, one person at a time.
Colorado’s rules do have a closer precedent. When a voter casts a ballot in a legislative or county commissioner vacancy election he isn’t eligible for, Rule 18 says to duplicate the ballot and leave that contest blank. That’s the right tool for Sterling Ranch. It says nothing about voter-ID batches.
Mrs. Davis’s description doesn’t match the state’s. The state sorts most ballots by ballot style and sends Sterling Ranch to hand review. Mrs. Davis talked about sorting envelopes by voter ID into batches and switching 7A off.
Arapahoe County describes a third way. According to the Sun, where an entire precinct is ineligible, Arapahoe’s staff leave that precinct out when they report 7A results to the state, no matter what voters marked. Arapahoe found 14 precincts where neighbors are split between eligible and ineligible. The state’s guidance named two such places across all four counties. Douglas County hasn’t said how many split precincts it has.
Maybe these are three ways of describing the same plan. Maybe they aren’t. I’d like to see Douglas County’s in writing.
The difference matters to me. Under the state’s method, my ballot carries its own style code. The machine reads it and ignores my 7A, wherever my ballot lands. Under the method Mrs. Davis described, it depends on which pile my envelope went into at the sorter.
Once my ballot leaves that envelope, nobody on earth can trace it back to me.
That’s the secret ballot, and I want it.
It also means that if my envelope lands in the wrong pile, nobody will ever know. Nobody can fix it.
The demonstration tested the filter. It didn’t test the pile.
* * *
I asked the obvious question. What happens to mine?
Here’s my best reading of the state’s instructions. My ballot shouldn’t be duplicated. My neighborhood isn’t in the district at all, so the machine is supposed to ignore 7A on ballots like mine. Everything else I marked still counts. My NO stays on the paper, kept with the rest of the ballots, counted by no one.
That’s my best reading. It rests on a state memo, a county web page and a television interview.
If I lived in Arapahoe County, I’d now have an answer. My precinct would be left out of the 7A report, whatever I marked. In Douglas County, nobody has said.
I can’t tell you whether the machine records my NO and then throws it out, or never captures it at all. I can’t tell you how the county checks that every envelope landed in the right pile. I can’t tell you whether 7A will be one of the contests the Secretary of State picks for the audit Colorado runs after every election. That choice gets made the Friday after Election Day. I went looking for the rest of those answers. They aren’t public.
Colorado’s ballot tracking will tell me my ballot arrived and was accepted. It won’t tell me what happened to my NO.
* * *
The other side’s case goes like this.
The error was caught before a single vote was counted. Most of the fix is routine machine work. The hand copying has real guardrails: two election judges from different parties at every table, each original ballot numbered and kept alongside its copy, and a written log of every one. Even if Douglas County botched the whole thing, only a few thousand eligible votes are in play here, in a district that stretches from Fort Collins to Pueblo. Doug Spencer, a University of Colorado law professor, told The Denver Post it was a disorganized mess that won’t change the outcome.
On the math, he’s probably right. The guardrails are real, too.
Then Professor Spencer said the part that matters. He told the Post the mistake will feed the argument that mail ballots aren’t secure.
Bingo.
My worry is the voter who already doubts the system. You know some of them. Maybe you’re one of them. For years, Colorado officials have called our mail-ballot system the gold standard. Now look at what the fix depends on.
Machines programmed to ignore marks a voter actually made. Election workers filling out new ballots on voters’ behalf. Envelopes sorted into piles nobody can ever trace back. A filter demonstrated on ballots that weren’t real.
Every one of those is something the skeptics already distrust.
Last week the rail district hired a former Jefferson County clerk, Pam Anderson, as an election advisor. Her message to voters, in the Sun: vote your ballot, and know that election officials are doing what they need to do to count it accurately and transparently.
The answer to the biggest ballot error anyone can remember comes down to this: trust us harder.
* * *
Douglas County can repair this before results come in. No lawsuit. No records request. Five things, and most of the paperwork already exists:
• Publish the written 7A procedure. The real one, the one the staff actually follows.
• Publish the count from the duplication log the state’s rules already require.
• Open the envelope sort, the step that matters, to the public and to both parties’ watchers.
• Ask the Secretary of State to make 7A one of Douglas County’s audited contests.
• After the canvass, publish the reconciliation: eligible ballots returned, 7A votes counted, ballots duplicated.
There’s also a test every one of us can run on election night, no special access required.
Only voters in Sterling Ranch and Douglas County’s sliver of Littleton can vote on 7A. 9News counted 5,967 in Sterling Ranch. When the county posts results, add the YES and NO votes on 7A together. If the total is a few thousand, the filter probably worked. If the total is 40,000, or 140,000, it didn’t.
Mrs. Davis, give us the denominator now. How many eligible voters live in that sliver of Littleton? How many eligible 7A ballots have come back? Post those numbers before the results, so nobody has to take anybody’s word for anything.
* * *
My NO is sitting with the rest of Douglas County’s ballots. My ballot has been received. BallotTrax told me it has been received and accepted. It’s exactly what I meant it to be. A vote that shouldn’t count.
I believe it won’t.
I’d just like somebody to show me.
Did 7A show up on your ballot? Did you vote on it, skip it, or not notice? Tell me in the comments, and tell me why.
Sourcing and Verification
• Senate Bill 26-172 (2026), as amended in the second house, Colorado General Assembly. The new district list: 31 named municipalities, including Littleton, plus Sterling Ranch Colorado Metropolitan Districts 1 through 7 in unincorporated Douglas County; the old district’s reach into 13 counties.
• Colorado Department of State and Colorado County Clerks Association, joint statement, October 7, 2026. The error was found October 6; the rail district did not adequately communicate its new boundaries; voters should return the ballot they were sent; ballot processing begins October 19.
• Douglas County Elections, “Voter resources for the Nov. 3, 2026, General Election,” posted October 12, 2026. 7A is on every Douglas County ballot; eligible areas are the portion of Littleton within Douglas County and Sterling Ranch Metropolitan Districts 1 through 7; voting on 7A or leaving it blank does not affect the rest of the ballot.
• Colorado Election Rules, 8 CCR 1505-1. Rule 18.4 (duplication by bipartisan resolution boards, Orig/Dupe numbering, required duplication log, and Rule 18.4.2 for ineligible voters in vacancy elections); Rule 25 (risk-limiting audit target contests selected by the Secretary of State by the Friday after Election Day).
• Denver7, Tyler Melito, “How Douglas County plans to ensure Ballot Issue 7A votes are correctly counted,” October 18, 2026. Clerk Sheri Davis’s description of the counting plan and her instruction to fill out 7A; the election worker’s account of the test demonstration.
• Denver7, “Questions raised due to Colorado ballot issue,” October 2026. Mrs. Davis’s statement that the only map the district provided showed all of Douglas County.
• 9News, October 7, 2026. 289,000 Douglas County voters received 7A; 5,967 in Sterling Ranch are eligible.
• Colorado Public Radio, October 7, 2026. Text of the Secretary of State’s guidance on hand review and duplication.
• The Colorado Sun, “’A fair amount of heartburn’: Arapahoe County figures out how to fix train ballot question mistake,” October 19, 2026. About 282,800 Douglas County voters and about 835,000 voters overall received 7A by mistake; Bill Mast on the unanswered email, the district’s outdated website map, the district’s decision not to withdraw 7A, Arapahoe’s precinct-exclusion method and its 14 split precincts; the rail district’s hiring of Pam Anderson.
• The Colorado Sun, October 7 and 8, 2026. State instruction to program voting systems for eligible voters only; how the 0.333% tax applies to purchases inside the district.
• The Denver Gazette / Colorado Politics, October 8 and 10, 2026. Judd Choate’s guidance, issued Wednesday night, October 7; Bow Mar and Sterling Ranch as the mixed-eligibility exceptions; testing protocols.
• The Denver Post, via Tribune Content Agency, October 9, 2026. Wayne Williams on the scale of the error and the state’s share of blame; Steve Schleiker’s July email and use of the bill; Doug Spencer on outcome and public confidence.
• CBS Colorado, October 2026. Weld County Clerk Carly Koppes on identifying ballot styles by barcodes and timing marks.
• FOX31/KDVR, October 2026. Secretary of State’s position on boundary notification; Sal Pace on the district’s lack of a legal obligation.
• Douglas County 2026 primary sample ballot and BallotReady. Sheri Davis, Republican, incumbent candidate for Clerk and Recorder.
Corrections and tips: michaelbrown@iheartmedia.com



Thanks, Mr. Brown. Unincorporated Douglas County resident here, it was on my ballot and I voted my preference, which was NO
This gets even stranger when you see the millions spent across 60 organizations, a general manager who earns a bonus for this ballot effort and the network of other passengers sitting in the first class car.
https://hartbeatofthecity.substack.com/p/coco-connection-how-an-entrenched-insider-network-is-buying-the-vote?r=8q5edz&utm_medium=ios&shareImageVariant=card