18 Comments
User's avatar
Chan Bailey's avatar

I agree that conservation is running short on funds, and would like to see them be better funded. Why is their funding low? Because they abuse the very people who pay the most - the hunters and anglers. Not only do those fees increase by unreasonable amounts on a regular basis, hunters/anglers pay a special tax on the equipment used for their recreation. To top it off they are treated like rapists, instead of the true conservationists they are. That is why fewer people hunt/fish than used to - the cost and public demonization. Some states have started adding a tax to camping equipment to help fund conservation. Regardless of where you use the tent, your backyard or a state campground you pay the tax.

Taking the photography tax (I'm sorry, "fee") to the next level, like hunting equipment, the next step will be to tax the camera, memory card, lens, tripod, everything. Hunting equipment, fishing gear, camping gear, photography gear all taxed plus outlandish fees will leave those activities to only those who can afford it. Add in the state fees to camp, park, etc. on public land and the public won't be able to afford using their own land.

If we don't find a way to stop it the end result may be a fee on air, once the communists decide they own that as well.

Michael D Brown's avatar

I should add your comment as an addendum to the article itself. Well said.

Chan Bailey's avatar

Thanks, and feel free to use it. Keep up the good work.

Katie Kirkland's avatar

So, many things are wrong with this (many of which you cover), but add to it the irony that Colorado often brags about being a state friendly to artists. This is a direct attack on those artists who already remit sales tax and pay income and self-employment taxes from the sales of their work (not that paying taxes or not is a reason to add more taxes or assault the First Amendment).

Howard Paul's avatar

ASMP Colorado comments to CPW Commission regarding a citizen petition to create a wildlife photographer permit.

Final-submitted August 27, 2026

A. Offering for future sale a photograph that portrays Colorado wildlife is a complicated business endeavor. For example, as a commercial photographer I occasionally sell a photograph of a mountain goat, but it is not my primary field of work. My last such image was sold to Colorado Parks & Wildlife’s magazine annual edition that showcases Colorado’s wildlife, November/December 2024.

In the future, would you require a permit for every year I offer such for private sale or a license for commercial use, only in the year in which a sale is consummated? This is asking a photographer (or simply a passing nature lover) to have a crystal ball and look into the future to see if the images they are making might be sold one day.

B. If on assignment for an international manufacturer of wind turbines I photograph a wind farm and in the foreground is a fence as a compositional element, and on that fence is a bird that falls under the purview of CPW, must I have a permit for that image used to promote sustainable energy resources?

The designation of “commercial” is an incorrect assessment. A professional photographer who leaves no trace, is alone, and respects wildlife has monumentally less impact on wildlife than others. Yet the professional is required to pay, and the group is not (under this proposed action). The deciding factor should be the impact, not commerce.

C. Do we, as a state, want to deprive both tourism revenue and national and international standing? Colorado in particular benefits from photographers bringing the natural beauty of the land to others through their images. All for a likely infinitesimally tiny collection of revenue, such that photographers are “on a par” with other supporters of wildlife that purchase a license of one sort or another—such as I do as an individual?

D. While this proposal might be permissible, it is extraordinarily overly broad and virtually unenforceable, except in an ex post facto analysis that would require an expense likely to be infinitely greater than the income generated.

Shutterstock.com alone has 19,194,787 wildlife stock images, according to its website, from across the planet. And its database currently holds 116,145 mountain goat stock photos. If enacted how would the permit function be enforced on this company that reported Q2 2026 revenue of $221.8 million?

E. The American Society of Media Photographers – Colorado Chapter urges you to file this petition request for CPW create a “Wildlife Photographer/Artist Permit” requiring anyone who sells, licenses, or commercially distributes photographs or artistic depictions of Colorado wildlife to obtain an annual permit in the “considered and deemed unpractical request” file.

IamTigger's avatar

How exactly are they going to prove that the picture I sold on Etsy was taken in Colorado. How are going to enforce me, a citizen of Texas, who happened to vacation in Durango, into paying for pictures of wildlife I might sell in Amarillo, or Lubbock, or Austin. Are they going to create a picture patrol to follow me to make sure I pay? Seems like Ms. Dorsey is creating an unenforceable mandate to make money for a failing system. Why hunt in Colorado where I pay exorbitant fees to stay, eat, and be entertained on my hunting trip when I can do the same for half the cost in Billings, Montana? Or Cody, Wyoming? Or Idaho Falls, Idaho? And, in those places, people are genuinely happy to see you, tell you the best places to go, and what to use. In Colorado, not so much.

Michael D Brown's avatar

They won't and they can't. I think this fails on Free Speech grounds alone. But, it shows the insanity of Colorado state government in 2026. It's why Colorado has turned deep blue. Don't let it happen to Texas.

Cindy H's avatar

You have the most interesting stories. A tax on a photograph? When you think you can’t hear anything more absurd, the termites come out of the woodwork. Thanks for sharing Michael. Keep them coming.

Michael D Brown's avatar

Thank you. I wish the news didn't make it this easy. :)

Howard Paul's avatar

COMMENTS OF ASMP AND NANPA

Opposition to the Citizen Petition for an Annual Wildlife Photographer / Artist Permit

Chair and Commissioners:

My name is Thomas Maddrey, and I serve as the Chief Executive Officer of the American

Society of Media Photographers (ASMP). I submit these comments on behalf of ASMP and the North American Nature Photography Association (NANPA). In total, our organization represents more than 7,500 photographers with nearly 1,800 dedicated nature and wildlife photographers, many of whom live and work in Colorado. My role is to advocate for photographers, the photography industry, and responsible photography practices. Period. Our position is equally direct: the Commission should deny this petition in full.

This proposal is a misguided, statewide content-taxation scheme for photography and art, not a measured conservation rule. It would require photographers, artists, publishers, stock agencies, platforms, and other businesses to pay the State before selling or licensing visual works simply because those works depict wildlife. It seeks to control images and art created on private property, away from CPW land, and without any measurable effect on an animal or habitat. It expressly covers a litany of uses, backed by threatened penalties.1 It is a targeted attack against the very people who champion the protection of wildlife, not only by their words, but in their actions, through their livelihoods, and in their efforts to create a record of the beauty and majesty of the world.

Photography is the visual language through which people encounter those places and wildlife

they may never see firsthand. Colorado, Colorado citizens, and Colorado businesses all benefit when photographers reveal and share the beauty and importance of its wildlife. This petition would suppress that work, burden the smallest of small creative businesses, diminish the public's connection to nature, and tell the world that Colorado sees wildlife imagery not as art and a dedicated craft, but as an offense. Put simply, it hurts each of us, photographers, wildlife, and lands included.

I. The proposal is a content-based burden on protected expression.

The permit is triggered by the content of an image. To enforce it, the State must inspect the

work, decide whether it depicts a covered species, determine whether wildlife is a "primary content driver," and classify the transaction as commercial, journalistic, scientific, or something else. A photograph of an elk is taxed; a photograph made in the same place, with the same equipment and the same environmental footprint, is not. The petition's exemptions for selected news and scientific uses add further distinctions based on the purpose and identity of the speaker. The Supreme Court has made clear that a rule is content based when it applies because of the topic or message expressed, and that visual art does not need a narrow, articulable message to receive First Amendment protection.

2 This is also a prior restraint. The permit must be obtained before the work may be distributed, and any scheme that conditions expression on advance permission bears a heavy presumption against its constitutional validity.

3 Payment does not transform a photograph into a harm to lands and wildlife, and compensation does not erase the expressive nature of art.

4 The State may regulate harmful conduct on land. It may

not make the right to distribute an image depend on paying for the subject matter shown in that image. At a minimum, this proposal presents grave First Amendment problems that the petition neither acknowledges nor analyzes.

II. The petition stretches CPW's authority beyond wildlife and into art.

Colorado law defines "wildlife" as wild vertebrates, mollusks, and crustaceans, including their

parts, products, eggs, and offspring. A photograph is not an animal, an animal part, or an animal

product under any reading. The petition even cites the wrong subsection - section 33-1-102 (57),

rather than the current subsection (51), as well as claiming coverage of insects even though insects are not included in that statutory definition.

5 The Commission's authority to control the sale, transfer, possession, or transportation of

wildlife is authority over the wildlife itself. The licensing provisions address hunting, fishing, and

other activities for which Title 33 expressly requires authorization. They do not grant an open-ended power to license expressive works merely because the works depict a species that CPW manages.

6 Colorado courts may set aside agency action that exceeds statutory authority or conflicts with constitutional rights, while agencies have broad discretion to decline requests for rulemaking. The legally responsible course is to deny this petition, not to initiate a costly process around a rule CPW has no clear authority to adopt.7

III. Conservation rules should follow impact, not income.

The petition gets the basic conservation question backward. A lone professional photographer using hand-carried equipment, staying on an open trail, and leaving no trace may have no more impact than any other visitor. A group of twenty noncommercial visitors may block access, trample natural grasses and landscapes, disturb animals, or damage habitat. Under this proposal, the low-impact professional pays because an image might at some unforeseen future date earn money, while the high-impact group does not because its images are not sold.

ASMP and NANPA successfully fought a similar fight at the federal level. Congress has now

rejected this same commercial / noncommercial distinction when it enacted the Federal Interior Lands Media Act (FILM Act) as section 125 of the EXPLORE Act. The federal framework generally

removes permits and fees for small crews that use public areas without disturbing resources, intruding on visitors, requiring exclusive use, using sets, or generating administrative costs. The FILM Act expressly provides that compensation does not determine whether the activity is permissible. Colorado is not bound to copy federal law, but it should learn from its sound principle: regulate actual footprint, not the later value of the images created.8

ASMP and NANPA support clear, evenhanded rules against harassment of wildlife, baiting

where prohibited, unsafe conduct, unlawful drone use, entry into closed areas, resource damage,

visitor obstruction, and exclusive or unusually burdensome productions. NANPA, in particular, is a

leading voice on ethical photography in the wild. These rules protect wildlife because they address conduct. This petition does not.

IV. The proposal is unworkable, arbitrary, and unsupported.

The petition sets no minimum revenue threshold. By its own terms, a single transaction is

enough. A one-time print sale, a greeting card, an old image later licensed to a magazine, or a wildlife-themed item sold by a small nonprofit could trigger the permit. An individual operating through an LLC is pushed into the $250 entity tier, and then penalized for having sound business practices. The proposal does not clearly resolve whether both creator and publisher may need separate permits, how anyone proves where an image was made, how an enforcement officer identifies a generic species in a stylized work, or what makes wildlife a "primary content driver" online.

The petition offers no cited market study, constitutional analysis, or other evidence that

commercial images cause wildlife or habitat harm. Instead, it asserts unsourced income percentages and market size, then admits that the permit should apply even to one transaction regardless of revenue.

V. Conclusion

Colorado can seek broader, fairer conservation funding through the General Assembly and a

transparent process that applies to the public as a whole. It should not single out photographers and artists, tax the content of their work, and threaten them with wildlife penalties for selling expression that harmed no wildlife, and in fact, demonstrably does the opposite.

You do not conserve wildlife by charging people for pictures of wildlife. ASMP and NANPA

respectfully urge the Commission to deny the citizen petition in full.10

Respectfully submitted,

Thomas Maddrey

Chief Executive Officer

American Society of Media Photographers

On behalf of ASMP and NANPA

Michael D Brown's avatar

Excellent response. Congratulations and I hope they listen to you!

No's avatar

Two questions

- if I sell my elk photo to a gallery, does the gallery also have to buy a license?

IDK's avatar
Sep 26Edited

In 2012 SCOTUS ruled that the "individual mandate" in the ACA, although referred to as a "penalty" was really a tax.

How does "fee" differ from "penalty"? The "fee" on photographs needs to be ratified by the voters under TABOR. It is a TAX.

Eric Dew's avatar

B___ll___t! First. This is method of quoting natural phenomenon for expression of opinion. Second. Would a sculpture of a rabbit be taxable when sold for an Easter decoration? Third. The government does not create wealth. Finally. The citizens personal and business endeavor is not a bottomless well of currency! Sooner, than later, there is just not enough cash to fund everybodys' desire for skimable funds for any/all 'noble' desires regardless of perceived desire to benefit any facton of the population.

IDK's avatar

Sounds like you're trying to say something. Keep working - maybe you'll do it some day.

Steve Hostetler's avatar

I'm a professional photographer. I photograph Colorado's wild horses (and other wildlife I may see along the way). I am strongly opposed to this kind of intrusive permit and fees. I have submitted my written objection to the CPW Commission. One of my questions to them would be, how do they intend to enforce this? I believe it would be very difficult to prove where the animal was located when it was photographed, unless they demanded metadata from the image (which I can turn off). How do I know when I make the image (thousands actually), that it will be sold or published where it could be monetized? They have no rights to my intellectual property (Copyright). I pay sales taxes to the state for physical images sold. I pay Colorado Income tax and Property taxes. The thing that bothers me the most, is that we don't physically take the animal from the land. Hunters and Fishermen do. I'm not in a position to accidentally shoot someone if I mid-identify my target. The whole idea of this is just another money grab by our Colorado Government. The list of reasons to leave Colorado gets longer every day... Hopefully they'll abandon this tax grab.

Mike's avatar

Blaming TABOR is just stupid. Blame Democrats for creating bogus ways around it.

Michael D Brown's avatar

I don't blame TABOR. I blame the "fee enterprise" the Democrats put in place to do a runaround on TABOR.